Key Takeaways
- • David Einhorn's Greenlight Capital exited its entire positions in PayPal (PYPL), StubHub (STUB) and Spectrum Brands (SPB) in the quarter ended Sept. 30, according to its 13F filed Nov. 16.
- • Greenlight's positions at June 30 were 1.42 million PayPal shares worth $62 million, 4.23 million StubHub shares worth $54 million, and 561,438 Spectrum Brands shares worth $48 million, per the filing as reported by TIKR.
- • Since June 30, PayPal is up 36%, StubHub is down 62% and Spectrum Brands is down 2%, with the figures reflecting share price moves only, not Greenlight's actual exit prices.
- • PayPal's third-quarter adjusted EPS rose 8% to $1.45, beating the $1.31 consensus, while branded checkout growth slowed to 1% to 2% and Barclays downgraded the stock to Underweight.
- • StubHub's average analyst target fell from $24 a year ago to $9, while Spectrum Brands' average target climbed from $78 to $98, with the stock trading at about 16x forward earnings.
Summary
Per TIKR's analysis, PayPal's fundamentals support the rally. Third-quarter adjusted EPS rose 8% to $1.45, versus $1.31 expected by analysts and a management forecast of a small decline. Revenue of $8.58 billion missed estimates, but non-transaction expenses grew only 1%, and management raised its year-end savings target to more than $700 million. Analysts' average price target fell from $83 to $57 over the past year, now about 3% below the share price. The main weakness is branded checkout, the PayPal button that generates over half of its profit, which grew only 1% to 2%. Barclays downgraded the stock to Underweight.
StubHub's story diverges sharply. Greenlight held 4.23 million shares worth $54 million at June 30, or 1.4% of its 13F equity holdings, and the stock has since fallen 62%. On Nov. 10, StubHub reported third-quarter gross merchandise sales up 7% to $2.6 billion and adjusted EBITDA up 84% to $124.1 million, a 25% margin, and raised its full-year sales outlook. Analysts' average target has nonetheless fallen from $24 a year ago to $9, with the lowest target at $6.50 against a $4.89 share price. The stock trades at about 13x forward earnings.
Spectrum Brands has seen analysts raise targets. Greenlight held 561,438 shares worth $48 million at June 30, or 1.2% of its 13F equity holdings. The stock is down 2% since then after rising from about $56 a year ago to $83.76. The average target climbed from $78 last December to $98, with all eight analysts' targets above the price and the lowest at $87, implying 17% average upside. At about 16x forward earnings, it is the most expensive of the three.
TIKR's author favors PayPal, which trades at about 10x forward earnings versus a 3-year average of 13x on TIKR. Analysts raised 2026 EPS estimates to $5.58 from $5.39, and consensus reaches $6.41 by 2028. Diluted shares fell to 882 million in the second quarter from 977 million a year earlier. Michael Burry, who has held PayPal since April, still calls it a "Fat Pitch." The key risk is branded checkout growth remaining at 1% to 2%, in which case buybacks would need to drive per-share growth. Key upcoming events include PayPal's fourth-quarter report in early February and Greenlight's next 13F, due mid-February.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.