Key Takeaways
- • Goldman Sachs traders achieved 85 trading days exceeding $100 million in profits during 2022, compared to 47 in 2021, with particularly strong performance in rates and commodities trading.
- • Global markets division generated 56% of Goldman's overall revenues, yet executives warned this week that compensation for the division "will be slashed by a low double-digit percentage"—a sharp reversal from industry expectations of 10–13% increases in rates, commodities, and FX roles.
- • The compensation cut reflects structural headwinds: Marcus (app-based banking) is expected to lose $1.2 billion this year; Platform Solutions is posting significant losses; technology infrastructure spending is rising; and return on equity is at risk of falling into single digits.
- • Industry benchmark data from search firm Options Group shows only credit traders expect compensation declines; rates and commodities professionals were anticipating meaningful raises, making Goldman's announcement an outlier in the competitive talent market.
- • Internal deliberations and potential adjustments to the bonus pool are underway as Goldman traders voice complaints about the unexpected reduction despite exceptional trading performance.
Summary
Goldman Sachs traders face a stark compensation reality despite delivering exceptional financial performance in 2022. The firm's trading division logged 85 days with profits exceeding $100 million this year—nearly double the 47 such days recorded in 2021. The outperformance was particularly pronounced in the third quarter, where Goldman's traders generated 22 six-figure days compared to just four for Morgan Stanley, underscoring the division's skill and the firm's appetite for risk-taking in volatile markets.
Yet this performance is not translating into expected rewards. According to Bloomberg reporting cited in the primary source, Goldman Sachs executives issued a warning this week to global markets division leadership that compensation "will be slashed by a low double-digit percentage." This announcement contradicts broader market expectations: search firm Options Group reports that traders across the industry are anticipating compensation increases of 10–13% in rates, commodities, and FX trading, with only credit traders expecting declines. Goldman's announcement therefore represents a sharp divergence from competitive peer compensation dynamics during a period of exceptional trading profits.
The root cause of the compensation contraction lies in structural profitability challenges elsewhere in the organization. Marcus, Goldman's app-based consumer banking platform, is projected to post a $1.2 billion loss in 2022. Platform Solutions, the newly formed unit housing the firm's credit card and installment lending business, is expected to generate significant losses. Simultaneously, technology infrastructure spending is rising, and the firm's return on equity faces pressure, potentially slipping into single digits. These headwinds have collectively constrained the capital available for trader compensation despite global markets contributing 56% of the firm's overall revenues.
The reaction has been swift. Goldman traders have begun lodging internal complaints, and Bloomberg reports active "internal deliberations" regarding potential adjustments to the bonus pool figures. The tension between exceptional trading performance and firm-wide profitability constraints highlights a recurring institutional challenge: departmental excellence does not guarantee proportional compensation when consolidated corporate returns are under pressure, particularly when non-core business units are generating substantial losses.
Yet this performance is not translating into expected rewards. According to Bloomberg reporting cited in the primary source, Goldman Sachs executives issued a warning this week to global markets division leadership that compensation "will be slashed by a low double-digit percentage." This announcement contradicts broader market expectations: search firm Options Group reports that traders across the industry are anticipating compensation increases of 10–13% in rates, commodities, and FX trading, with only credit traders expecting declines. Goldman's announcement therefore represents a sharp divergence from competitive peer compensation dynamics during a period of exceptional trading profits.
The root cause of the compensation contraction lies in structural profitability challenges elsewhere in the organization. Marcus, Goldman's app-based consumer banking platform, is projected to post a $1.2 billion loss in 2022. Platform Solutions, the newly formed unit housing the firm's credit card and installment lending business, is expected to generate significant losses. Simultaneously, technology infrastructure spending is rising, and the firm's return on equity faces pressure, potentially slipping into single digits. These headwinds have collectively constrained the capital available for trader compensation despite global markets contributing 56% of the firm's overall revenues.
The reaction has been swift. Goldman traders have begun lodging internal complaints, and Bloomberg reports active "internal deliberations" regarding potential adjustments to the bonus pool figures. The tension between exceptional trading performance and firm-wide profitability constraints highlights a recurring institutional challenge: departmental excellence does not guarantee proportional compensation when consolidated corporate returns are under pressure, particularly when non-core business units are generating substantial losses.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.