Key Takeaways
- • Long/short equity hedge funds have failed to capitalize on a 25% decline in equity markets over the past 12 months, leaving significant performance gaps relative to market conditions that should have favored hedged strategies.
- • Newly established hedge fund managers lack the conviction and trading discipline required for effective short-selling, a core competency for capturing downside protection in long/short strategies.
- • The underperformance suggests a structural challenge: equity market declines alone do not guarantee hedge fund profitability without sophisticated execution on the short side of portfolios.
Summary
Long/short equity hedge funds have significantly underperformed relative to market conditions that should have created favorable opportunities for hedged strategies. With equity markets declining 25% over the preceding 12-month period as of April 2017, these funds have failed to leverage what appears to be a substantial tailwind for strategies explicitly designed to profit from downside moves through short positions.
The core issue identified in the market is a skills gap among newer fund managers entering the hedge fund space. Many recent entrants to long/short equity management have discovered that short-selling demands a fundamentally different discipline than the long equity investing many practitioners bring from traditional asset management backgrounds. Effective shorting requires not merely theoretical understanding but sustained conviction in thesis development, rigorous risk management, and superior trading execution—capabilities that many fresh managers underestimated upon entering the hedge fund industry.
This performance deficit reveals an important market dynamic: equity declines alone do not automatically translate into hedge fund gains. Success in capturing downside requires both portfolio construction sophistication and operational execution on the short book that goes substantially beyond traditional equity investing skill sets. The divergence between market conditions and hedge fund returns underscores why experienced short-sellers command premium valuations in the alternative investment space, while managers without this specific expertise struggle to deliver on the hedge fund value proposition even during favorable market environments.
The core issue identified in the market is a skills gap among newer fund managers entering the hedge fund space. Many recent entrants to long/short equity management have discovered that short-selling demands a fundamentally different discipline than the long equity investing many practitioners bring from traditional asset management backgrounds. Effective shorting requires not merely theoretical understanding but sustained conviction in thesis development, rigorous risk management, and superior trading execution—capabilities that many fresh managers underestimated upon entering the hedge fund industry.
This performance deficit reveals an important market dynamic: equity declines alone do not automatically translate into hedge fund gains. Success in capturing downside requires both portfolio construction sophistication and operational execution on the short book that goes substantially beyond traditional equity investing skill sets. The divergence between market conditions and hedge fund returns underscores why experienced short-sellers command premium valuations in the alternative investment space, while managers without this specific expertise struggle to deliver on the hedge fund value proposition even during favorable market environments.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.