Key Takeaways
- • Third Point CEO Daniel Loeb released a four-minute activist video on October 18, 2018, titled "Empty the Can," parodying Campbell Soup's iconic "Mmm, Mmm, Good" jingle as "Mmm, Mmm, Bad" to mobilize shareholder support for board replacement at the November 29 shareholder meeting.
- • The Dorrance family, which controls approximately 41 percent of Campbell Soup's shares, publicly backed the current board on October 17, directly countering Third Point's ouster campaign and positioning themselves as a decisive voting bloc in the proxy contest.
- • Campbell Soup completed a strategic review in early October 2018 that recommended focusing on two "distinct businesses"—Snacks and Meals & Beverages—while divesting non-core Campbell International and Campbell Fresh divisions, signaling acknowledgment of operational challenges including declining soup sales.
- • The activist campaign centers on allegations of failed board leadership and "dismal soup sales," with Third Point's criticism intensifying following CEO Denise Morrison's sudden departure in May 2018 and the company's prior acquisitions of Snyder's-Lance and Bolthouse Farms that have not reversed revenue decline in core business segments.
Summary
Third Point LLC, led by hedge fund manager Daniel Loeb, escalated its proxy battle for control of Campbell Soup Company on October 18, 2018, releasing a provocative four-minute video designed to sway retail and institutional shareholders ahead of the company's November 29 annual meeting. The video, titled "Empty the Can," weaponizes Campbell's most recognizable marketing asset—the "Mmm, Mmm, Good" jingle—by altering the final lyrics to "Mmm, Mmm, Bad." The production strategy appears calculated to leverage nostalgia and brand recognition while delivering a stark critique of current board governance.
The timing and intensity of Third Point's campaign reflects genuine strategic discord. Campbell Soup announced completion of a board-led strategic review on October 4, 2018, which itself implicitly acknowledged operational distress. The review, initiated in May 2018 following CEO Denise Morrison's sudden retirement, recommended narrowing focus to Snacks and Meals & Beverages operations while divesting Campbell International and Campbell Fresh as non-core assets. This represents a significant strategic retrenchment from prior diversification efforts, including the acquisitions of Snyder's-Lance and Bolthouse Farms, which have failed to offset declining soup sales.
The Dorrance family, descendants of Campbell founder John Dorrance, emerged as a critical counterweight to Third Point's activism. On October 17, family members including board members Bennett Dorrance, Mary Alice Dorrance Malone, and Archbold van Beuren announced their support for the incumbent board. With approximately 41 percent shareholding, the Dorrance family possesses sufficient voting power to materially influence the outcome of the shareholder meeting, creating a three-way dynamic between Third Point, the Dorrance family, and independent institutional shareholders.
The proxy contest reflects broader tensions in the packaged food industry, where legacy soup-centric business models face secular headwinds from changing consumer preferences. Third Point's video criticism citing "dismal soup sales" and leadership failure targets institutional and retail shareholders concerned about value destruction and strategic underperformance. The November 29 shareholder meeting will determine whether activist pressure overcomes family entrenchment and board confidence in the newly announced strategic pivot.
The timing and intensity of Third Point's campaign reflects genuine strategic discord. Campbell Soup announced completion of a board-led strategic review on October 4, 2018, which itself implicitly acknowledged operational distress. The review, initiated in May 2018 following CEO Denise Morrison's sudden retirement, recommended narrowing focus to Snacks and Meals & Beverages operations while divesting Campbell International and Campbell Fresh as non-core assets. This represents a significant strategic retrenchment from prior diversification efforts, including the acquisitions of Snyder's-Lance and Bolthouse Farms, which have failed to offset declining soup sales.
The Dorrance family, descendants of Campbell founder John Dorrance, emerged as a critical counterweight to Third Point's activism. On October 17, family members including board members Bennett Dorrance, Mary Alice Dorrance Malone, and Archbold van Beuren announced their support for the incumbent board. With approximately 41 percent shareholding, the Dorrance family possesses sufficient voting power to materially influence the outcome of the shareholder meeting, creating a three-way dynamic between Third Point, the Dorrance family, and independent institutional shareholders.
The proxy contest reflects broader tensions in the packaged food industry, where legacy soup-centric business models face secular headwinds from changing consumer preferences. Third Point's video criticism citing "dismal soup sales" and leadership failure targets institutional and retail shareholders concerned about value destruction and strategic underperformance. The November 29 shareholder meeting will determine whether activist pressure overcomes family entrenchment and board confidence in the newly announced strategic pivot.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.