Key Takeaways
- • The Credit Suisse Liquid Alternative Beta Index registered negative returns of -0.4% in June 2010, with year-to-date performance at -0.12%, signaling broad-based underperformance across the hedge fund industry in the first half of 2010.
- • Hedge funds have failed to build meaningfully on their robust 2009 recovery, which saw the HFRX Global Hedge Fund Index deliver 23%+ returns following the 23.3% decline in 2008, indicating stagnation relative to investor expectations.
- • Merger arbitrage and event-driven strategies demonstrated relative resilience, with the LAB Merger Arbitrage Index posting 4.04% year-to-date returns and the LAB Event Driven Index achieving 1.61%, outperforming the broader hedge fund benchmark.
- • Multiple fund tracking sources—including CS/Tremont, Hedge Fund Research, and Hennessee—corroborate the sluggish performance narrative, suggesting industry-wide weakness rather than isolated underperformance.
- • Regulatory headwinds in Europe and the US are constraining hedge fund activities amid the muted return environment, adding structural pressure on fund operations and investor sentiment.
Summary
Hedge funds have logged disappointing returns in the first half of 2010, according to aggregated performance data from Credit Suisse and independent fund trackers. The Credit Suisse Liquid Alternative Beta Index, a comprehensive measure designed to reflect overall hedge fund industry returns, recorded a -0.4% decline in June alone, bringing year-to-date performance to -0.12%. This marginal negative figure starkly contrasts with the industry's strong rebound in 2009, when the HFRX Global Hedge Fund Index achieved returns exceeding 23%, a significant recovery from the 23.3% losses sustained during the 2008 financial crisis.
The sluggish performance represents a marked deceleration in momentum. Fund trackers including CS/Tremont, Hedge Fund Research, and Hennessee all point to similar trends of stagnation across the broader hedge fund landscape, indicating that the industry has struggled to sustain the gains achieved over the previous year. Investors and allocators anticipated continued improvement following the crisis-driven losses of 2008 and the recovery gains of 2009, but mid-year 2010 data suggest those expectations have not materialized.
Not all hedge fund strategies performed equally. Certain specialized approaches demonstrated relative strength. The LAB Merger Arbitrage Index logged year-to-date returns of 4.04% as of June, while the LAB Event Driven Index achieved 1.61%, both outpacing the negative overall benchmark. These indices are part of the Liquid Alternative Beta series, which employs objective, rules-based methodologies to replicate aggregate returns of alternative investment strategies using tradable instruments and transparent weighting frameworks.
The performance challenges occur against a backdrop of tightening regulatory constraints on hedge fund activities, particularly in Europe and the United States. These regulatory pressures add structural headwinds to operational efficiency and investment flexibility, compounding the difficulty of generating returns in a tepid macro environment. The combination of weak performance and increased regulatory oversight has created a challenging operating environment for the hedge fund industry as the second half of 2010 approaches.
The sluggish performance represents a marked deceleration in momentum. Fund trackers including CS/Tremont, Hedge Fund Research, and Hennessee all point to similar trends of stagnation across the broader hedge fund landscape, indicating that the industry has struggled to sustain the gains achieved over the previous year. Investors and allocators anticipated continued improvement following the crisis-driven losses of 2008 and the recovery gains of 2009, but mid-year 2010 data suggest those expectations have not materialized.
Not all hedge fund strategies performed equally. Certain specialized approaches demonstrated relative strength. The LAB Merger Arbitrage Index logged year-to-date returns of 4.04% as of June, while the LAB Event Driven Index achieved 1.61%, both outpacing the negative overall benchmark. These indices are part of the Liquid Alternative Beta series, which employs objective, rules-based methodologies to replicate aggregate returns of alternative investment strategies using tradable instruments and transparent weighting frameworks.
The performance challenges occur against a backdrop of tightening regulatory constraints on hedge fund activities, particularly in Europe and the United States. These regulatory pressures add structural headwinds to operational efficiency and investment flexibility, compounding the difficulty of generating returns in a tepid macro environment. The combination of weak performance and increased regulatory oversight has created a challenging operating environment for the hedge fund industry as the second half of 2010 approaches.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.