Key Takeaways
- • The New Jersey State Investment Council unanimously voted to reduce the pension fund's hedge fund allocation target from 6% to 3%, cutting exposure in half effective immediately.
- • The current market value of hedge fund holdings stood at $4.3 billion as of April 30, 2019, with the reduction targeting approximately $2 billion in total hedge fund investments going forward.
- • Labor unions successfully pressured the state pension system to reduce allocations, citing excessive fees charged by hedge fund managers as a primary concern.
- • The $72 billion pension system serves over 837,000 public employees, making this a material shift in asset allocation strategy for one of the nation's largest public pension funds.
- • The decision reflects broader institutional skepticism toward hedge fund performance and fee structures, part of a multi-year trend of pension fund de-risking from alternative investments.
Summary
The New Jersey State Investment Council approved a significant reduction in hedge fund exposure on May 29, 2019, cutting the pension system's target allocation to hedge funds in half—from 6% to 3%—in a unanimous vote. The decision, finalized on Wednesday, responds to sustained pressure from labor unions seeking to minimize fee payments to alternative investment managers. As of April 30, 2019, the pension fund held approximately $4.3 billion in hedge fund positions, with the new allocation target reducing this to roughly $2 billion.
The action represents a major strategic shift for New Jersey's $72 billion pension system, which supports retirement benefits for more than 837,000 public employees. The cost of hedge fund management—typically structured with 2% annual management fees plus 20% performance fees—has become an increasingly contentious issue for public pension funds facing mounting liabilities and pressure from beneficiaries and their unions to optimize fee structures.
The reduction marks a continuation of New Jersey's broader retreat from hedge fund allocations. Previous investment strategy revisions had already trimmed hedge fund exposure substantially, and this latest move accelerates that trend. Labor unions and pension advocates have argued that lower-cost, passive investment strategies could deliver comparable returns with significantly reduced drag from manager fees, potentially saving taxpayers billions in retirement system costs over multi-decade periods.
The unanimous approval suggests broad consensus among New Jersey's investment leadership regarding the prudence of reallocating capital away from fee-intensive hedge fund partnerships toward alternative investment vehicles or traditional index-tracking strategies. This decision aligns with similar moves by other large institutional investors reassessing the value proposition of hedge fund allocations relative to their embedded costs.
The action represents a major strategic shift for New Jersey's $72 billion pension system, which supports retirement benefits for more than 837,000 public employees. The cost of hedge fund management—typically structured with 2% annual management fees plus 20% performance fees—has become an increasingly contentious issue for public pension funds facing mounting liabilities and pressure from beneficiaries and their unions to optimize fee structures.
The reduction marks a continuation of New Jersey's broader retreat from hedge fund allocations. Previous investment strategy revisions had already trimmed hedge fund exposure substantially, and this latest move accelerates that trend. Labor unions and pension advocates have argued that lower-cost, passive investment strategies could deliver comparable returns with significantly reduced drag from manager fees, potentially saving taxpayers billions in retirement system costs over multi-decade periods.
The unanimous approval suggests broad consensus among New Jersey's investment leadership regarding the prudence of reallocating capital away from fee-intensive hedge fund partnerships toward alternative investment vehicles or traditional index-tracking strategies. This decision aligns with similar moves by other large institutional investors reassessing the value proposition of hedge fund allocations relative to their embedded costs.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.