Key Takeaways
- • The share of U.S. corporate defined benefit pension funds investing in hedge funds rose to 24% in 2006, up from 19% in 2004 and 12% in 2000, according to a Congressional Research Service report dated June 15, 2007.
- • Total corporate pension assets allocated to hedge funds reached 2.1% in 2006, up from 1.3% in 2003, per Greenwich Associates data cited in the report.
- • The SEC's 2004 rule requiring many hedge fund advisers to register under the Investment Advisers Act took effect in February 2006 but was vacated by a court in June 2006.
- • Congress asked the Government Accountability Office to examine hedge fund use by public and private defined benefit plan sponsors, while the Bush Administration favored increased vigilance over new rules.
- • San Diego County Employees Retirement Association estimated a $100 million loss from its Amaranth investment yet still returned 14.57% in 2006 and keeps $1.2 billion (15% of its $8 billion portfolio) in hedge funds and alternatives.
Summary
The report notes that the hedge fund industry has grown rapidly, with an estimated 8,800 funds managing about $1.2 trillion in 2006, a roughly 3,000% increase in assets over 16 years. It also highlights regulatory developments. In 2004 the SEC required many hedge fund advisers to register under the Investment Advisers Act. That rule took effect in February 2006, but a court challenge upheld in June 2006 vacated it. In early 2007 the Bush Administration called for increased vigilance rather than new rules, while Congress asked the GAO to examine defined benefit plan use of hedge funds.
The report cites concerns about leverage, opacity and fund failures. Long-Term Capital Management's 1998 collapse required a Federal Reserve Bank of New York-engineered bailout, while Amaranth Advisors lost $6.4 billion from a $9 billion peak in September 2006 on natural gas speculation without triggering Fed action. The CRS also notes that hedge funds are exempt from SEC registration and examination, which the SEC argues limits investors' access to material information.
The report argues that the appropriateness of hedge funds for pensions depends on portfolio context. Individual hedge fund investments carry the risk of total loss, but as portfolio components they can provide diversification and reduce volatility. The report cites a Boeing plan that will raise alternatives, including hedge funds, from 2% to 14% of assets, per Fundfire. It also describes San Diego County Employees Retirement Association's experience: after a $100 million loss tied to Amaranth, the fund still earned 14.57% in the prior year and continues to allocate $1.2 billion to hedge funds and other alternatives while suing Amaranth.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.