Key Takeaways
- • First Trust launches forensic accounting-based long/short ETF: First Trust Advisors debuted the First Trust Long/Short Equity ETF (FTLS) on September 9, employing proprietary methodology to identify companies with aggressive accounting practices (low-quality earnings) for shorting and conservative companies for longing.
- • Early performance exceeds benchmark with lower volatility: Through November 20, FTLS outperformed the S&P 500 by approximately 60 basis points (0.57%) while delivering significantly lower volatility than the broad index.
- • Long/short equity strategies demonstrate 20-year historical outperformance: Over two decades, long/short hedge funds have cumulatively outperformed the S&P 500 benchmark by 62% while maintaining one-third less volatility, suggesting structural advantages despite recent S&P 500 strength.
- • FTLS positioning targets 80–100% long exposure with 0–50% short allocation: The fund's portfolio construction balances long equity positions in higher-quality companies against selective short positions in lower-quality accounting names.
- • Long/short equity variants proliferate despite 15% S&P 500 annual gains: Despite strong passive index performance, alternative managers continue developing specialized long/short products, indicating persistent institutional demand for equity market-neutral and quality-focused strategies.
Summary
The long/short equity fund category continues to attract new product launches and asset manager attention despite the S&P 500's 15% return over the prior 12 months, a performance backdrop that might seem to favor passive indexing through low-cost vehicles like SPY and IVV. First Trust Advisors recently entered this competitive landscape by launching FTLS, an actively managed exchange-traded fund that employs forensic accounting analysis to differentiate investment targets. The fund's strategy, as explained by First Trust's Ryan Issakainen, measures the aggressiveness of accounting practices at publicly traded companies, using the hypothesis that firms with low-quality or aggressive earnings tend to underperform, while conservative-accounting companies generate superior returns.
FTLS's early performance supports this thesis. Since its September 9 launch through November 20, the fund outperformed the S&P 500 by approximately 60 basis points while exhibiting significantly lower volatility than the benchmark. This early track record aligns with the fund's stated positioning: 80–100% long exposure in high-quality accounting names combined with zero to 50% short positions in lower-quality companies, creating a tilted but not market-neutral posture.
Historical data provides context for this strategy's long-term viability. Over a 20-year track record, long/short hedge funds as a category have cumulatively exceeded S&P 500 returns by 62% while maintaining approximately one-third less volatility. This risk-adjusted outperformance, despite significant periods of equity market strength, suggests fundamental advantages embedded in active stock selection and short discipline. However, the distinction between broad hedge fund "long/short" strategies—which may include bonds, currencies, and derivatives—and equity-only long/short products remains important for institutional investors evaluating performance attribution and strategy purity.
The persistence of long/short equity product launches reflects sustained institutional demand for alternatives to passive beta exposure and pure long-only equity strategies, particularly among investors seeking to mitigate drawdowns through short positioning and exploit security-level pricing inefficiencies through forensic accounting or other analytical frameworks.
FTLS's early performance supports this thesis. Since its September 9 launch through November 20, the fund outperformed the S&P 500 by approximately 60 basis points while exhibiting significantly lower volatility than the benchmark. This early track record aligns with the fund's stated positioning: 80–100% long exposure in high-quality accounting names combined with zero to 50% short positions in lower-quality companies, creating a tilted but not market-neutral posture.
Historical data provides context for this strategy's long-term viability. Over a 20-year track record, long/short hedge funds as a category have cumulatively exceeded S&P 500 returns by 62% while maintaining approximately one-third less volatility. This risk-adjusted outperformance, despite significant periods of equity market strength, suggests fundamental advantages embedded in active stock selection and short discipline. However, the distinction between broad hedge fund "long/short" strategies—which may include bonds, currencies, and derivatives—and equity-only long/short products remains important for institutional investors evaluating performance attribution and strategy purity.
The persistence of long/short equity product launches reflects sustained institutional demand for alternatives to passive beta exposure and pure long-only equity strategies, particularly among investors seeking to mitigate drawdowns through short positioning and exploit security-level pricing inefficiencies through forensic accounting or other analytical frameworks.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.