Key Takeaways
- • Hedge funds are reviving "portable alpha," a decades-old strategy largely abandoned after the 2008 financial crisis, to attract investors in a challenging fundraising environment characterized by higher interest rates and increased competition.
- • Portable alpha combines passive index exposure (such as S&P 500 or MSCI World benchmarks) with actively managed alpha from systematic equities, commodity trading, relative value, or multistrategy approaches, designed to deliver benchmark returns plus uncorrelated gains without materially increasing risk or expenses.
- • Major hedge funds including Balyasny, Man Group, Squarepoint, and Winton have already adopted portable alpha strategies, with numerous peers actively exploring the approach in investor conversations, signaling broad industry adoption.
- • Prime brokers at major institutions—including Morgan Stanley's Kim Shaw and Penny Novick—are reporting steady momentum around portable alpha in 2024, indicating institutional demand for the structure in a higher-rate environment seeking enhanced returns.
- • The strategy's resurgence reflects hedge funds' pivot toward offering investors punchier returns through customizable combinations of passive benchmarks and active strategies, repositioning index investing as a competitive alternative to traditional hedge fund offerings.
Summary
Hedge funds are experiencing a revival of "portable alpha," a strategy developed in the 1980s that fell out of favor after the 2008 financial crisis. Facing a challenging fundraising climate dominated by higher interest rates and intense competition for capital, the industry is leveraging this approach to attract institutional investors with a proposition that merges passive and active investing.
Portable alpha works by pairing exposure to a passive benchmark—such as the S&P 500 or MSCI World index—with actively managed alpha generated through various strategies including systematic equities, commodity trading advisors, relative value, or multistrategy vehicles. The goal is to deliver investors benchmark performance plus uncorrelated returns without materially increasing risk or fees. As Kim Shaw, global cohead of prime brokerage at Morgan Stanley, noted in an interview: "Your goal is to get punchier returns in a higher-rate environment." The strategy derives its name from the flexibility to customize which active strategy complements a given index or ETF exposure.
The approach has already gained traction among elite hedge fund managers. Balyasny, Man Group, Squarepoint, and Winton have embraced portable alpha structures, according to people familiar with the firms. Beyond these leaders, a broader set of hedge funds are actively exploring the strategy in investor conversations. Prime brokers including Morgan Stanley, represented by Shaw and her global cohead Penny Novick, have reported a steady drumbeat of intrigue about portable alpha throughout 2024—a sentiment corroborated by other prime brokers, hedge fund managers, and industry consultants.
The resurgence represents a strategic repositioning by the hedge fund industry. Rather than competing solely on active stock-picking prowess, managers are offering investors the best of both worlds: the stability and cost efficiency of index exposure combined with the upside potential of active management. This hybrid approach addresses investor concerns about fee structures and performance in a higher-rate environment while providing hedge funds with a differentiated offering in a crowded marketplace.
Portable alpha works by pairing exposure to a passive benchmark—such as the S&P 500 or MSCI World index—with actively managed alpha generated through various strategies including systematic equities, commodity trading advisors, relative value, or multistrategy vehicles. The goal is to deliver investors benchmark performance plus uncorrelated returns without materially increasing risk or fees. As Kim Shaw, global cohead of prime brokerage at Morgan Stanley, noted in an interview: "Your goal is to get punchier returns in a higher-rate environment." The strategy derives its name from the flexibility to customize which active strategy complements a given index or ETF exposure.
The approach has already gained traction among elite hedge fund managers. Balyasny, Man Group, Squarepoint, and Winton have embraced portable alpha structures, according to people familiar with the firms. Beyond these leaders, a broader set of hedge funds are actively exploring the strategy in investor conversations. Prime brokers including Morgan Stanley, represented by Shaw and her global cohead Penny Novick, have reported a steady drumbeat of intrigue about portable alpha throughout 2024—a sentiment corroborated by other prime brokers, hedge fund managers, and industry consultants.
The resurgence represents a strategic repositioning by the hedge fund industry. Rather than competing solely on active stock-picking prowess, managers are offering investors the best of both worlds: the stability and cost efficiency of index exposure combined with the upside potential of active management. This hybrid approach addresses investor concerns about fee structures and performance in a higher-rate environment while providing hedge funds with a differentiated offering in a crowded marketplace.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.