Key Takeaways
- • Orange County Employees Retirement System (OCERS), a $20.8 billion California pension fund, has placed Ray Dalio's Bridgewater Associates Pure Alpha hedge fund on its watch list due to trailing performance concerns, with the $175 million position representing just over 6% of the plan's assets.
- • Pure Alpha has underperformed its benchmark by approximately 2.5 percentage points annualized since 2005, returning 4.5% versus a benchmark of Treasury bill yield plus 5 percentage points, with consistent shortfalls across three-, five-, and seven-year measurement periods since 2015.
- • In the first half of 2021 alone, Pure Alpha returned 1.9%—0.7 percentage points below benchmark performance—underscoring recent weakness relative to broader equity markets, which have delivered higher returns over the 16-year tenure.
- • OCERS CIO Molly Murphy stated the watch list placement is not a termination decision, indicating the fund will remain under continuous monitoring with potential outcomes ranging from continued investment to full exit, pending future performance assessment.
- • Despite the underperformance narrative, Pure Alpha has generated approximately 6.4% annually for OCERS over its 16-year history with just one negative year, though the S&P 500 has outpaced it at 8.8% annualized over the same period.
Summary
The Orange County Employees Retirement System, a $20.8 billion California county pension plan, has placed Ray Dalio's flagship hedge fund Pure Alpha on its investment watch list, signaling potential exit consideration based on persistent underperformance. The action reflects growing dissatisfaction with the $175 million Bridgewater Associates position, which constitutes just over 6% of OCERS' total assets.
According to analysis by the plan's consultant Meketa Investment Group, Pure Alpha has delivered annualized returns of 4.5% since 2005—roughly 2.5 percentage points below its stated benchmark of Treasury bill yields plus 5 percentage points. The deterioration has been particularly pronounced since 2015, with the fund falling short of benchmarks across all trailing measurement periods through June 30, 2021. In the first half of 2021, Pure Alpha's 1.9% return lagged its benchmark by 0.7 percentage points, continuing a trend of relative weakness.
Molly Murphy, OCERS' Chief Investment Officer, clarified that the watch list designation does not constitute an imminent termination. In a statement, Murphy noted that OCERS "continually assess all of our investment managers and some stay in the portfolio and come off watch, while others do not and are terminated, but it is not prescribed." This framing indicates the fund faces a probationary period during which Meketa and OCERS will monitor performance and determine whether Pure Alpha merits continued investment.
Contextually, despite recent underperformance, Pure Alpha has delivered meaningful absolute returns for OCERS over its 16-year tenure, generating approximately 6.4% annually with only one negative year, according to sources familiar with the arrangement. However, this performance has trailed the S&P 500, which has returned 8.8% annualized over the same span—a significant gap that likely prompted OCERS' scrutiny and explains why a hedge fund with historically positive performance now faces exit consideration.
The decision underscores institutional investor reappraisal of hedge fund value propositions during an extended bull market, where lower-volatility absolute return strategies have struggled to justify fee structures relative to passive equity exposure. For Bridgewater, one of the world's largest hedge funds managing over $150 billion, OCERS' reassessment represents a notable vote of no confidence from a significant institutional allocator.
According to analysis by the plan's consultant Meketa Investment Group, Pure Alpha has delivered annualized returns of 4.5% since 2005—roughly 2.5 percentage points below its stated benchmark of Treasury bill yields plus 5 percentage points. The deterioration has been particularly pronounced since 2015, with the fund falling short of benchmarks across all trailing measurement periods through June 30, 2021. In the first half of 2021, Pure Alpha's 1.9% return lagged its benchmark by 0.7 percentage points, continuing a trend of relative weakness.
Molly Murphy, OCERS' Chief Investment Officer, clarified that the watch list designation does not constitute an imminent termination. In a statement, Murphy noted that OCERS "continually assess all of our investment managers and some stay in the portfolio and come off watch, while others do not and are terminated, but it is not prescribed." This framing indicates the fund faces a probationary period during which Meketa and OCERS will monitor performance and determine whether Pure Alpha merits continued investment.
Contextually, despite recent underperformance, Pure Alpha has delivered meaningful absolute returns for OCERS over its 16-year tenure, generating approximately 6.4% annually with only one negative year, according to sources familiar with the arrangement. However, this performance has trailed the S&P 500, which has returned 8.8% annualized over the same span—a significant gap that likely prompted OCERS' scrutiny and explains why a hedge fund with historically positive performance now faces exit consideration.
The decision underscores institutional investor reappraisal of hedge fund value propositions during an extended bull market, where lower-volatility absolute return strategies have struggled to justify fee structures relative to passive equity exposure. For Bridgewater, one of the world's largest hedge funds managing over $150 billion, OCERS' reassessment represents a notable vote of no confidence from a significant institutional allocator.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.