Key Takeaways
- • Women-led hedge funds returned 3.65% in the first two months of 2017, outperforming the broader hedge fund industry's 2.23% return by 142 basis points, according to Hedge Fund Research data.
- • A $1 million investment with a female hedge fund manager would have generated $36,500 in gains versus $22,300 in the typical male-run hedge fund—a $14,200 advantage—over the same January-February 2017 period.
- • Women-managed funds represent only 49 of approximately 2,100 hedge funds tracked by HFR, comprising just 2% of the industry despite their outperformance.
- • The S&P 500 significantly outpaced all hedge fund strategies, returning 5.94% over the two-month period and reinforcing Warren Buffett's decade-long wager that passive index funds would beat active hedge fund management.
- • The broader hedge fund industry posted a 5.46% gain for 2016 after losses in 2015, yet continues to underperform equities—a pattern consistent since the 2008 financial crisis.
Summary
Women-managed hedge funds are delivering superior returns relative to industry peers in early 2017, though the absolute performance advantage remains modest against broader equity benchmarks. Through the first two months of the year, funds owned or managed by women generated 3.65% returns compared to 2.23% for the overall hedge fund industry, representing a statistically significant 142-basis-point outperformance gap. This translates to tangible capital differential: a $1 million allocation to a female-led hedge fund manager would have accumulated $36,500 in gains versus $22,300 in a typical hedge fund, yielding a $14,200 performance advantage.
Despite these relative gains, the data underscores persistent structural challenges within hedge fund management. The universe of women-led funds remains critically small—only 49 funds managed by women exist within HFR's index of approximately 2,100 total hedge funds, representing barely 2% of the industry. This concentration limitation may skew performance metrics and highlights the profound underrepresentation of female managers in the sector.
The broader hedge fund industry context presents a more sobering picture for active management. The HFRI Fund Weighted Composite Index rose 5.46% in 2016 following declines in 2015, yet hedge fund performance has consistently lagged the S&P 500 every year since 2008. During the January-February 2017 window examined in this analysis, the S&P 500 returned 5.94% inclusive of dividends, outperforming every single hedge fund strategy tracked by HFR. This dynamic reinforces Warren Buffett's "Million-Dollar Bet" thesis—a decade-long wager that a Vanguard S&P 500 index fund would outperform hedge funds over time. After nine years, Buffett's index fund has returned 85.4% compared to the best-performing hedge fund challenger at 62.8%, validating the passive indexing argument. Even activist hedge funds, positioned to benefit from market dislocations and stock-specific catalysts, started 2017 with mediocre returns despite two S&P 500 constituents posting significant gains driven by activist campaigns.
Despite these relative gains, the data underscores persistent structural challenges within hedge fund management. The universe of women-led funds remains critically small—only 49 funds managed by women exist within HFR's index of approximately 2,100 total hedge funds, representing barely 2% of the industry. This concentration limitation may skew performance metrics and highlights the profound underrepresentation of female managers in the sector.
The broader hedge fund industry context presents a more sobering picture for active management. The HFRI Fund Weighted Composite Index rose 5.46% in 2016 following declines in 2015, yet hedge fund performance has consistently lagged the S&P 500 every year since 2008. During the January-February 2017 window examined in this analysis, the S&P 500 returned 5.94% inclusive of dividends, outperforming every single hedge fund strategy tracked by HFR. This dynamic reinforces Warren Buffett's "Million-Dollar Bet" thesis—a decade-long wager that a Vanguard S&P 500 index fund would outperform hedge funds over time. After nine years, Buffett's index fund has returned 85.4% compared to the best-performing hedge fund challenger at 62.8%, validating the passive indexing argument. Even activist hedge funds, positioned to benefit from market dislocations and stock-specific catalysts, started 2017 with mediocre returns despite two S&P 500 constituents posting significant gains driven by activist campaigns.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.