Key Takeaways
- • Energy hedge funds down sharply despite perceived market opportunity: Traders managing power and natural gas positions are posting double-digit losses for 2013, despite believing commodity markets offer significant value opportunities.
- • Elustria Capital Partners shuts after three consecutive losing years: The power-focused hedge fund, launched in mid-2011 with $75 million by former Elliott Associates trader Andrew Waranch and Kottke Associates portfolio manager Eric Kimmel, posted losses of 3.2% (H2 2011), 4.35% (2012), and 9.24% (year-to-date through June 2013) before closing on October 29, 2013.
- • SandRidge Capital's natural gas fund also exits market: Andrew Rowe's energy-focused hedge fund shut down earlier in 2013, underscoring broader performance challenges in the sector.
- • Timing risk undermines fundamental thesis: Fund managers acknowledge that while power, natural gas, and electricity markets present attractive risk/reward profiles, the inability to predict entry points and near-term catalysts has made execution nearly impossible, forcing positions to cash.
- • Capital allocation pullback exerts downward price pressure: Two years of losses have deterred investors from committing fresh capital to longer-dated energy trades, creating a self-reinforcing cycle that pressures commodity valuations despite structural investment opportunities.
Summary
Energy hedge funds specializing in power and natural gas commodities are experiencing significant losses in 2013 despite widespread belief that markets present compelling investment opportunities. According to CNBC, traders managing these positions are down double-digits for the year, even as they maintain conviction that current valuations offer substantial value.
Elustria Capital Partners, a power-focused hedge fund, exemplified the sector's struggle before announcing closure on October 29, 2013. Launched in mid-2011 by Andrew Waranch (formerly of Elliott Associates) and Eric Kimmel (from Kottke Associates) with $75 million in initial capital, Elustria traded electricity, natural gas, and coal markets across a three-year operating period marked by consistent losses. The fund posted a 3.2% loss in the second half of 2011, declined 4.35% in 2012, and fell 9.24% through June 2013. Assets never expanded beyond the initial $75 million allocation, according to performance reports reviewed by CNBC.
In its October investor letter, Elustria articulated the strategic paradox confronting energy hedge funds: "The power market is screaming for investment. The challenges of the last two years have caused many to sour on allocating capital to longer-dated trades. This has led to a downward pressure on prices that we believe offers tremendous value." However, the fund acknowledged that timing entry points remained fundamentally unpredictable, and without visibility to near-term catalysts to revalue the forward curve, positions often had to be liquidated to cash rather than held for realization.
The Elustria closure was not isolated. Andrew Rowe's natural gas-focused hedge fund SandRidge Capital also shut operations earlier in 2013. The pattern reflects a structural challenge: deteriorating fund performance has discouraged fresh capital allocation to longer-dated energy trades, creating persistent downward price pressure that, while theoretically attractive on fundamental grounds, has proven operationally devastating to levered hedge fund positions dependent on either capital appreciation or portfolio stability.
Elustria Capital Partners, a power-focused hedge fund, exemplified the sector's struggle before announcing closure on October 29, 2013. Launched in mid-2011 by Andrew Waranch (formerly of Elliott Associates) and Eric Kimmel (from Kottke Associates) with $75 million in initial capital, Elustria traded electricity, natural gas, and coal markets across a three-year operating period marked by consistent losses. The fund posted a 3.2% loss in the second half of 2011, declined 4.35% in 2012, and fell 9.24% through June 2013. Assets never expanded beyond the initial $75 million allocation, according to performance reports reviewed by CNBC.
In its October investor letter, Elustria articulated the strategic paradox confronting energy hedge funds: "The power market is screaming for investment. The challenges of the last two years have caused many to sour on allocating capital to longer-dated trades. This has led to a downward pressure on prices that we believe offers tremendous value." However, the fund acknowledged that timing entry points remained fundamentally unpredictable, and without visibility to near-term catalysts to revalue the forward curve, positions often had to be liquidated to cash rather than held for realization.
The Elustria closure was not isolated. Andrew Rowe's natural gas-focused hedge fund SandRidge Capital also shut operations earlier in 2013. The pattern reflects a structural challenge: deteriorating fund performance has discouraged fresh capital allocation to longer-dated energy trades, creating persistent downward price pressure that, while theoretically attractive on fundamental grounds, has proven operationally devastating to levered hedge fund positions dependent on either capital appreciation or portfolio stability.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.