AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Good and Bad Volatility: A Recipe for Success or Disaster

Reported by Iasg
Nov 17, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • The article argues that volatility is not uniformly beneficial: fundamentally driven, persistent moves create futures trading opportunities, while erratic, noise-driven swings are difficult for most strategies to exploit.
  • • Following the 2026 midterm election, large daily price ranges created an environment that was risky to trade but offered opportunities, with oil prices falling more than 7% in one session on speculation the Iran conflict might wind down faster.
  • • The author cites Harvard economist Jason Furman's estimate that data center and associated investment accounted for 92% of 2025 US GDP growth, and S&P Global's figure that this spending drove 80% of private domestic demand growth over the same period.
  • • Option sellers and trend followers can benefit from noisy markets: option sellers collect elevated premiums, while trend followers can hold through choppiness, though daily returns vary widely.
  • • The piece concludes that disciplined traders should size risk, prepare for adverse moves, and sit out when no clear pattern or basis for a position exists.
Summary
A commentary published by Fortune and drawing on S&P Global analysis distinguishes between "good" volatility, driven by real information and fundamentals, and "bad" volatility, which is largely noise. The author notes that the strongest periods for most futures strategies tend to occur during extreme market stress, but that erratic day-to-day swings are difficult for most investment styles. In a market dominated by systematic trading, false signals are amplified, and noise can drive short-term direction in thin markets such as overnight sessions or summer periods. The author argues that genuine fundamental drivers ultimately produce follow-through and trends that persist for days rather than hours.

The article describes the post-midterm period as an example of this dynamic. A sweeping Democratic victory was viewed as a rebuke of the Trump administration, yet with the executive branch unchanged, the odds of major legislation remained low. Speculation that the Iran conflict might end sooner pushed oil prices down more than 7% the following day. An equity rally reversed quickly on concerns, prompted by social media posts, that the new congressional majority might pursue AI companies. The author adds that the ouster of Jensen Huang at Nvidia, alongside corporate earnings, appeared to be driving markets roughly a week after the election.

The piece highlights data center development as a policy issue to watch. Citing Jason Furman, the author states that in 2025 data center investment and associated processing technology accounted for 92% of US GDP growth, and S&P Global figures show this spending drove 80% of private domestic demand growth over the same period. Critics point to high power consumption and upward pressure on electricity prices. The author acknowledges that the concern is valid but notes that power generation investment is ramping up, with longer lead times. The author also observes that the newly elected Texas governor has begun backing away from some earlier rhetoric on the issue.

On the strategy side, the article notes that option sellers can profit from noisy markets, since elevated volatility lifts premiums, though the environment can shift quickly into directional moves. Trend followers can also perform reasonably well because longer holding periods allow them to ride through choppiness, although returns can vary widely from day to day. The author concludes that the most successful traders prepare for adverse moves, limit risk when action is mainly noise, and focus on markets, such as commodities, where movement remains rational.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Iasg Good and Bad Volatility: A Recipe for Success or Disaster