Key Takeaways
- • "Through" target-date funds dominate the Morningstar 500 list, continuing to rebalance asset allocations three decades into retirement by shifting from equities to income-producing bonds, with American Funds Target Date Retirement series exemplifying this approach and carrying a Silver Medalist Rating.
- • American Funds differentiates strategy by emphasizing equity dividend payers alongside bond allocation, resulting in materially higher yields for retired cohorts: the 2015 Target Date Retirement fund (AABTX) yielded 2.9% at end-2024 versus 1.7% for the 2035 series (AAFTX).
- • JPMorgan SmartRetirement series represents the rare "to" target-date approach, freezing asset allocation at retirement with a 40% equity strategic allocation—below the 44% industry average—and carries a Neutral Morningstar rating, contrasting with the dominant "through" methodology.
- • Income generation strategies diverge meaningfully across target-date fund families, with allocation decisions during retirement years creating substantial yield differentiation that directly impacts retirees' cash flow outcomes.
Summary
Target-date retirement funds employ fundamentally different philosophies in generating income for retirees, reflecting a strategic divide between "through" and "to" approaches that produces measurable performance implications for investors in or approaching retirement.
The market is dominated by "through" target-date funds, which continue adjusting asset allocations well into the retirement phase, typically shifting capital from equities into income-producing bonds to manage sequence-of-returns risk and enhance yield. American Funds Target Date Retirement series exemplifies this methodology and maintains a Silver Medalist Rating from Morningstar. The firm differentiates its approach by directing capital not only into traditional bonds but also into equity dividend-paying funds such as American Funds Capital Income Builder (CAIBX), a Silver-rated holding. This dual-income strategy produces meaningful yield differentiation across vintage years: the American Funds 2015 Target Date Retirement fund (AABTX), serving investors already a decade into retirement, generated a 12-month yield of 2.9% as of end-2024, compared with 2.5% for the 2025 vintage (AADTX) and 1.7% for the 2035 vintage (AAFTX). This yield compression reflects the lower equity allocation and dividend income generation in younger cohorts.
In contrast, JPMorgan SmartRetirement's A-share series represents the industry outlier as a "to" target-date fund, freezing its strategic asset allocation upon the investor's retirement year. The series' equity allocation halts at 40%—notably below the 44% industry average—and maintains a Neutral Morningstar rating. This approach trades the flexibility and ongoing rebalancing of "through" funds for portfolio stability and reduced trading activity in the post-retirement phase.
The choice between these competing methodologies carries significant implications for institutional plan sponsors, family offices, and individual investors seeking retirement income solutions. The dominance of "through" funds in the Morningstar 500 reflects market consensus that ongoing asset mix adjustments better serve retirees facing multi-decade spending horizons, yet the availability of alternative approaches acknowledges legitimate differences in risk tolerance, behavioral preferences, and market expectations across investor cohorts.
The market is dominated by "through" target-date funds, which continue adjusting asset allocations well into the retirement phase, typically shifting capital from equities into income-producing bonds to manage sequence-of-returns risk and enhance yield. American Funds Target Date Retirement series exemplifies this methodology and maintains a Silver Medalist Rating from Morningstar. The firm differentiates its approach by directing capital not only into traditional bonds but also into equity dividend-paying funds such as American Funds Capital Income Builder (CAIBX), a Silver-rated holding. This dual-income strategy produces meaningful yield differentiation across vintage years: the American Funds 2015 Target Date Retirement fund (AABTX), serving investors already a decade into retirement, generated a 12-month yield of 2.9% as of end-2024, compared with 2.5% for the 2025 vintage (AADTX) and 1.7% for the 2035 vintage (AAFTX). This yield compression reflects the lower equity allocation and dividend income generation in younger cohorts.
In contrast, JPMorgan SmartRetirement's A-share series represents the industry outlier as a "to" target-date fund, freezing its strategic asset allocation upon the investor's retirement year. The series' equity allocation halts at 40%—notably below the 44% industry average—and maintains a Neutral Morningstar rating. This approach trades the flexibility and ongoing rebalancing of "through" funds for portfolio stability and reduced trading activity in the post-retirement phase.
The choice between these competing methodologies carries significant implications for institutional plan sponsors, family offices, and individual investors seeking retirement income solutions. The dominance of "through" funds in the Morningstar 500 reflects market consensus that ongoing asset mix adjustments better serve retirees facing multi-decade spending horizons, yet the availability of alternative approaches acknowledges legitimate differences in risk tolerance, behavioral preferences, and market expectations across investor cohorts.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.