AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

ASIC’s private credit review shows the headline fee covers only part of what managers earn - Investor Strategy News

Reported by Ioandc
Nov 19, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • ASIC Report 846, released 10 November, examined 24 private credit funds with about $18 billion under management, split evenly between retail and wholesale, finding that disclosed management fees capture only part of what managers and related entities earn.
  • • Nine of 12 wholesale private credit funds kept some or all of the establishment fees their borrowers paid, and only two of 22 comparable funds passed the full benefit of interest and borrower fees through to investors.
  • • Ten of the 12 wholesale funds used special purpose vehicles as a material part of their structure, and seven kept default borrower fees, with only three of those seven quantifying them in offer documents.
  • • In one ASIC example, a related-party lender's undisclosed income from margins and borrower fees exceeded four times the fund's disclosed management cost and received 38 cents per dollar distributed to investors.
  • • ASIC expects to consult in early 2027 on extending Regulatory Guide 45 to private credit funds generally, so institutions should write reconciliation requirements into mandates and side letters now.
Summary
Australia's Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) released Report 846 on 10 November, examining 24 private credit funds with about $18 billion under management, split evenly between retail and wholesale. According to the report, the management cost that allocators and consultants use to rank private credit managers may capture only part of what managers and their related entities earn. Nine of the 12 wholesale funds kept some or all of the establishment fees paid by borrowers, and of 22 funds whose fees could be compared, only two passed the full benefit of interest and borrower fees through to investors.

The wholesale half of the sample, holding $9.8 billion, is the segment most relevant to institutional portfolios. Ten of the 12 wholesale funds used special purpose vehicles as a material part of their structure, compared with three of 12 retail funds. Seven kept default fees charged to borrowers, in two cases without disclosure, and only three of those seven quantified the fees in their offer documents. ASIC also flagged two inter-fund transfers in which managers moved roughly 15 per cent and 17 per cent of fund assets to related funds during 2025, both in wholesale funds. ASIC commissioner Simone Constant said investors should not need forensic skills to understand how a fund operates.

Foresight Analytics, a Sydney ratings house, argues in its Diligence Spotlight paper that a fund with a visibly higher management cost that retains nothing else may be cheaper than one charging less while collecting more upstream. In the case ASIC used to illustrate the point, a related-party lender kept an interest margin and all borrower fees and default interest without disclosure, income exceeding four times the fund's disclosed management cost. ASIC measured margins retained above the fund at between zero and 5.9 per cent of the loan book across wholesale funds in 2025, which Foresight says means headline net yields can misstate the risk investors carry. Foresight also highlights that default interest accruing to related entities can create incentives that conflict with fund interests during deteriorating credit conditions.

The findings arrive as regulators tighten scrutiny of trustees. APRA estimated last week that private credit accounts for around 2 per cent of super fund assets, a figure it called conservative, and its proposed investment governance standard, open for consultation until 3 February, would require quarterly valuations. In October, ASIC found auditors lacked sufficient evidence for the value of $67 billion in externally managed unlisted investments, $6 billion of it private credit.

Foresight recommends that investment committees request a reconciliation of borrower payments against recorded fund revenue, the related-party transaction register, valuer instructions, and minutes approving inter-fund transfers. The paper cautions that ASIC's findings come from a sample and should not be mechanically extrapolated, and that origination and servicing are legitimate functions for which managers may charge. It also notes that Foresight sells the due diligence it recommends. ASIC expects to consult in early 2027 on extending Regulatory Guide 45 to private credit funds generally, though RG 45 currently covers retail mortgage schemes.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Ioandc ASIC’s private credit review shows the headline fee covers only part of what managers earn - Investor Strategy News