Key Takeaways
- • CVC's white paper argues that direct lending's track record of resilient performance rests on senior secured positioning, floating-rate income, stronger bilateral documentation and diversification, and that these features should matter more as market conditions shift.
- • The paper cites a spread premium of roughly 150bps over Broadly Syndicated Loan markets and says direct lending delivered higher annualised returns at lower volatility than leveraged loans and high yield over the past 10 years.
- • Software accounts for roughly 21% of aggregate U.S. BDC portfolio assets, versus 10.9% of private debt issuance in Europe and 17.6% in the U.S. over the past five years, which CVC uses to argue the recent stress is sector sentiment rather than systemic credit risk.
- • Europe is presented as under-penetrated, with companies still sourcing 88% of debt financing from banks, leaving room for further bank disintermediation.
- • The U.S. accounts for 72% of the MSCI World Index by market capitalisation, a concentration CVC says is prompting investors to rebalance toward European private credit.
Summary
CVC has published a white paper, "Designed for Durability," making the structural case for direct lending as private credit investors focus on selectivity, downside resilience and regional differentiation. The paper argues that the asset class's performance through past cycles rests on structural protections, disciplined underwriting and diversification, and that these strengths become more valuable when market narratives and macroeconomic conditions change.
CVC identifies several structural features: senior secured positioning at the top of the capital structure, a spread premium over Broadly Syndicated Loan markets currently around 150bps, stronger bilateral documentation, floating-rate coupons and direct lender control. The firm says these features helped direct lending deliver higher annualised returns at lower volatility than leveraged loan and high yield markets over the past decade. It also states that direct lending's risk-adjusted returns remain more attractive after adjusting for the smoothing effect of quarterly reporting, and that its correlation to the traditional 60/40 portfolio is markedly lower.
On software, CVC acknowledges that concentration in U.S. private credit portfolios has drawn bearish headlines this year. Software makes up roughly 21% of aggregate BDC portfolio assets, according to the paper, with higher proportions at some outlier funds. CVC argues the aggregate figure masks regional, fund-level and business-model differences. Software exposures reportedly range from zero to above 30% among some of the largest BDCs. The paper notes that some BDCs trade at double-digit discounts to NAV and that software defaults may rise, but characterises developments so far as a sentiment shock rather than a significant credit event. CVC says it has maintained a selective approach in European direct lending, with reduced software emphasis and a proprietary 'Software Scorecard' to assess AI-related risk.
The paper also makes the case for European growth. Companies still source 88% of debt financing from banks in Europe, which CVC says leaves considerable room for bank disintermediation. It notes that the U.S. accounts for 72% of the MSCI World Index and that the top 10 constituents, all U.S.-listed, represent 26% of the index. CVC argues this concentration is driving rebalancing toward European private markets. Midmarket companies with EBITDA of €25m–€100m are described as a core origination segment for private equity sponsors.
CVC identifies several structural features: senior secured positioning at the top of the capital structure, a spread premium over Broadly Syndicated Loan markets currently around 150bps, stronger bilateral documentation, floating-rate coupons and direct lender control. The firm says these features helped direct lending deliver higher annualised returns at lower volatility than leveraged loan and high yield markets over the past decade. It also states that direct lending's risk-adjusted returns remain more attractive after adjusting for the smoothing effect of quarterly reporting, and that its correlation to the traditional 60/40 portfolio is markedly lower.
On software, CVC acknowledges that concentration in U.S. private credit portfolios has drawn bearish headlines this year. Software makes up roughly 21% of aggregate BDC portfolio assets, according to the paper, with higher proportions at some outlier funds. CVC argues the aggregate figure masks regional, fund-level and business-model differences. Software exposures reportedly range from zero to above 30% among some of the largest BDCs. The paper notes that some BDCs trade at double-digit discounts to NAV and that software defaults may rise, but characterises developments so far as a sentiment shock rather than a significant credit event. CVC says it has maintained a selective approach in European direct lending, with reduced software emphasis and a proprietary 'Software Scorecard' to assess AI-related risk.
The paper also makes the case for European growth. Companies still source 88% of debt financing from banks in Europe, which CVC says leaves considerable room for bank disintermediation. It notes that the U.S. accounts for 72% of the MSCI World Index and that the top 10 constituents, all U.S.-listed, represent 26% of the index. CVC argues this concentration is driving rebalancing toward European private markets. Midmarket companies with EBITDA of €25m–€100m are described as a core origination segment for private equity sponsors.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.