Key Takeaways
- • Attorney and former banker Jim Woolery has filed four lawsuits on behalf of shareholders in four publicly traded business development companies (BDCs), targeting affiliates of large alternative asset managers that advise them, according to Puck.
- • The core legal theory alleges that affiliated investment advisers have continuously inflated the value of BDC portfolio assets in order to extract higher management fees than they were otherwise entitled to receive.
- • The challenge centers on privately held credit assets that do not trade, which are inherently difficult to value and therefore susceptible to valuation discretion.
- • The suits, filed earlier in the year, put fee structures and asset marks at private-credit managers under legal scrutiny, with the central question being whether the managers will be compelled to open their books.
Summary
The central legal argument, as described by Puck, is that the affiliated investment advisers have continuously inflated the value of assets held by the BDCs in order to extract more fees than they would otherwise have been entitled to receive. Because management fees in BDCs are typically tied to asset values, the valuation of holdings is the mechanism at the heart of the allegations.
Puck emphasizes that certain assets, particularly private credits that do not trade, are notoriously difficult to value properly. The article draws a comparison to the 2008 financial crisis, which it attributes to the failure of most Wall Street investment banks, with the notable exception of Goldman Sachs, to properly mark mortgage-backed securities they could not sell to outside investors. Puck notes that the 2008 failure was a matter of poor judgment rather than a legal issue, with serious consequences.
The article's publisher summary frames the open question as whether Woolery can compel the managers to open their books. The source material available for this summary is limited to the opening portion of the article, and the full text is behind a paywall.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.