Key Takeaways
- • Private debt funds are lending to firms that banks consider too risky and charging higher interest rates, according to a University of Chicago Booth and Trier University study; half of their corporate borrowers would not qualify for traditional bank financing.
- • The study surveyed 38 US and 153 European private-debt general partners and investment decision-makers in August and September 2021, representing more than $300 billion in combined AUM, or over a third of a roughly $1 trillion private debt market.
- • US funds averaged 42% leverage and European funds 11%, versus about 90% for bank lenders and over 80% for CLO funds; US funds targeted about 8.16% annual returns and European funds 8.7%.
- • Private debt lenders monitored borrowers more frequently than banks, with 85% of US private debt borrowers reporting at least monthly, compared with 50% of bank-syndicated loan borrowers in a Shared National Credit Program study.
- • Per a 2022 Preqin report, alternative lenders were projected to become the second-largest capital-lending source by 2023, behind private equity.
Summary
The researchers define the funds in question as vehicles that raise capital through private equity-style closed-end structures and make senior loans, largely on a direct-lending model in which a single lender or small group holds the loan to maturity. The survey covered 38 US and 153 European general partners and investment decision-makers in August and September 2021, representing more than $300 billion in AUM. Institutional capital, including insurance companies, pension funds and high-net-worth individuals, was the largest source of limited partner capital, similar to private equity.
Leverage was materially lower than at banks. US private debt funds averaged 42% leverage and European funds 11%, compared with roughly 90% at bank lenders and more than 80% at collateralized loan obligation funds. Target returns were 8.16% annually for US funds and 8.7% for European funds, compared with a German five-year bund yield of -0.7%, US five-year Treasuries below 1%, and US BB-rated bonds at roughly 3.2% at the time of the survey.
US managers targeted borrowers averaging about $290 million in revenue and just over 1,000 employees, while European managers focused on companies with roughly €170 million (about $180 million) in revenue and around 800 employees. US managers prioritized stable cash flows, while European managers weighted management, the underlying business and cash flows equally. Loans typically ran five to seven years. Unlike banks, these lenders avoided asset-based lending and favored cash-flow-based loans, and they monitored borrowers more often; 85% of US private debt borrowers reported at least monthly, versus 50% of bank-syndicated borrowers in a Shared National Credit Program study by Matthew Gustafson, Ivan Ivanov and Ralf Meisenzahl.
Some reports cited by the researchers indicate private debt has outperformed the leveraged loan and high-yield bond markets since 2004 despite lending to riskier borrowers. A July 2022 JPMorgan Chase announcement that it would create a direct lending unit may signal entry by large banks, but the researchers argue that banks will face a disadvantage from heavier regulation.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.