AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Fat payouts for HL's private equity raiders while its clients are hung out to dry: Alex Brummer

Reported by This-is-money ·Thisismoney
Nov 9, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Alex Brummer argues that private equity owners of Hargreaves Lansdown (HL) extracted £600 million in dividends in the 12 months to June 2026 and a further £189.3 million in the three months to September, according to figures he attributes to The Times.
  • • HL's private equity owners, including CVC, Nordic Capital and the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, took control in March 2025 after the previous board and shareholders accepted their buyout offer.
  • • Brummer says HL clients have suffered as popular funds were hit by volatility in technology and AI stocks, with one family member's ISA portfolio down 10 per cent.
  • • Brummer contrasts HL's conduct with Whitbread, whose board rejected activist Corvex's 6.3 per cent stake push for a sale and leaseback, with 91 per cent of votes excluding Corvex's shares backing the board.
  • • Brummer's column is an opinion piece critical of HL's treatment of Woodford fund investors and of UK boards that yield to private equity bidders.
Summary
Hargreaves Lansdown clients are facing a difficult period, according to a column by Alex Brummer. Many popular funds on the platform have been battered by volatility in technology and AI stocks, which dominate both index and active management. Brummer cites a family member whose individual savings account (Isa) was down 10 per cent on the latest HL app valuation, placing it in correction territory. That investor had cashed in some gains before the latest market turmoil.

Brummer's central criticism concerns the economics of HL's private equity ownership. CVC, Nordic Capital and the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority persuaded the previous board and shareholders to accept their offer in March 2025. Citing figures from The Times, Brummer writes that the owners extracted £600 million in dividends in the 12 months to June 2026 and a further £189.3 million in the three months to September. He also notes that the owners have invested £100 million in new systems, which he says is a necessary cost. He argues that the proceeds could instead have reduced management costs for clients, many of whom already pay higher dealing and management fees than rivals such as Aberdeen-owned Interactive Investor.

The column also revisits HL's handling of the Woodford collapse in 2019. Brummer writes that HL's Wealth List promoted Neil Woodford's flagship Equity Income Fund until its collapse, and that one-third of HL clients were exposed to Woodford directly or through HL's fund of funds. He says HL has offered no apology or direct compensation, and that legal redress has been slow.

Brummer contrasts these outcomes with Whitbread, where chairman Christine Hodgson and management rejected a push from Corvex, which held a 6.3 per cent stake. Corvex had urged a sale and leaseback of the property estate, a proposal Whitbread declined. At an extraordinary general meeting, 91 per cent of votes, excluding Corvex's shares, backed the board. Brummer also criticises KKR, which he says reported record quarterly profits and promised $40 billion of returns to clients.

This is an opinion column, and the criticisms are Brummer's own assessments.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

2 outlets

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

This-is-money Fat payouts for HL's private equity raiders while its clients are hung out to dry: Alex Brummer Thisismoney Fat payouts for HL's private equity raiders - while its loyal clients are hung out to dry: ALEX BRUMMER