Key Takeaways
- • The Private Equity Legal Alliance (PELA) released its fourth white paper, "Defending the Balance Sheet: Insurance Defense as Institutional Litigation Infrastructure," examining whether private equity and institutional capital can consolidate the fragmented insurance defense sector.
- • The paper cites research showing U.S. courts produced a record 135 nuclear verdicts ($10 million or more against corporate defendants) in 2024, with total awards reaching $31.3 billion.
- • U.S. property and casualty insurers incurred approximately $29 billion in defense and cost containment expenses across liability lines in 2025, according to the paper.
- • The white paper identifies carrier purchasing power, panel economics, attorney retention, technology adoption and MSO structures as the key factors determining whether an institutional defense platform can succeed.
- • Samson Partners Group's Seth Deutsch argues the model's success will depend on whether platforms can demonstrate measurable value to the carriers they serve, not simply on capital deployed or firms acquired.
Summary
The Private Equity Legal Alliance (PELA) has released its fourth white paper, "Defending the Balance Sheet: Insurance Defense as Institutional Litigation Infrastructure," according to a PRNewswire release. The paper extends PELA's earlier work, which focused on personal injury firms, legal management services organizations (MSOs) and scalable platforms, to insurance defense. The authors characterize that market as distinct because of its recurring institutional demand, longstanding carrier relationships, sophisticated billing requirements and fragmented network of law firms.
The paper is set against mounting cost pressure on property and casualty insurers. Citing research, it reports that U.S. courts produced a record 135 nuclear verdicts in 2024, with total awards reaching $31.3 billion, and that U.S. P&C insurers incurred roughly $29 billion in defense and cost containment expenses across liability lines in 2025, including outside counsel fees. The authors argue that carriers may benefit from defense partners able to deliver consistent litigation strategies, integrated data, stronger trial capabilities and greater operational efficiency across jurisdictions.
At the center of the analysis is the distinction between a traditional insurance defense firm and an institutional defense platform. Samson Partners Group's Seth Deutsch, founder and CEO, and Jordan McMillian, partner, contend that integrated case management, billing, data, technology and performance measurement could improve firm economics while giving carriers greater visibility. The report highlights AI-enabled workflows, integrated billing and collections, standardized reporting and litigation analytics as significant opportunities. It also addresses regulatory and operational preparation for institutional investment, including the use of MSO structures to separate business operations from the independent practice of law, and the new reporting systems, internal controls and governance requirements those structures entail.
Contributors include Neal McNamara of Virtas Partners, Arina Shulga of Fox Rothschild, Luke Snyder of CBIZ, Inc., and guest contributor Britt Gary of Catalex Network. The paper concludes that the opportunity will be determined by whether an institutional platform can demonstrate measurable value to carriers. The white paper and three prior PELA publications are available for free download through PELA member organizations and at samsonpartnersgroup.com/free-downloads.
The paper is set against mounting cost pressure on property and casualty insurers. Citing research, it reports that U.S. courts produced a record 135 nuclear verdicts in 2024, with total awards reaching $31.3 billion, and that U.S. P&C insurers incurred roughly $29 billion in defense and cost containment expenses across liability lines in 2025, including outside counsel fees. The authors argue that carriers may benefit from defense partners able to deliver consistent litigation strategies, integrated data, stronger trial capabilities and greater operational efficiency across jurisdictions.
At the center of the analysis is the distinction between a traditional insurance defense firm and an institutional defense platform. Samson Partners Group's Seth Deutsch, founder and CEO, and Jordan McMillian, partner, contend that integrated case management, billing, data, technology and performance measurement could improve firm economics while giving carriers greater visibility. The report highlights AI-enabled workflows, integrated billing and collections, standardized reporting and litigation analytics as significant opportunities. It also addresses regulatory and operational preparation for institutional investment, including the use of MSO structures to separate business operations from the independent practice of law, and the new reporting systems, internal controls and governance requirements those structures entail.
Contributors include Neal McNamara of Virtas Partners, Arina Shulga of Fox Rothschild, Luke Snyder of CBIZ, Inc., and guest contributor Britt Gary of Catalex Network. The paper concludes that the opportunity will be determined by whether an institutional platform can demonstrate measurable value to carriers. The white paper and three prior PELA publications are available for free download through PELA member organizations and at samsonpartnersgroup.com/free-downloads.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.