Key Takeaways
- • Thoma Bravo is transferring control of customer experience software firm Medallia to its lenders, resulting in a complete $5.1 billion equity wipeout for the private equity firm and co-investors who acquired the company for $6.4 billion in 2021.
- • Lenders including Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital—holding approximately $3 billion in Medallia debt—have already marked down the company's loans significantly, with valuations ranging from 74 to 79 cents on the dollar as of recent quarterly reports.
- • The Medallia collapse represents one of the most significant private equity failures from the post-pandemic buyout boom, when firms deployed capital into software assets at near-zero interest rates without anticipating sustained rate increases and operational challenges.
- • The restructuring reflects acute stress in the private credit sector, where business development companies are trading at their widest discounts to net asset values in 5.5 years (0.74 price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio as of end-March), with software-exposed portfolios facing particular pressure.
- • Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall attributed Medallia's underperformance to "execution-driven issues" rather than artificial intelligence displacement, though sector-wide concerns about software valuation sustainability persist.
Summary
Thoma Bravo has reached an agreement to hand over Medallia, a customer experience software platform, to its creditors in a restructuring that eliminates $5.1 billion in equity value for the sponsor and co-investors. The transaction represents the conclusion of months of negotiations following the company's inability to service approximately $3 billion in debt. Medallia was acquired by Thoma Bravo in 2021 for $6.4 billion during the low-interest-rate environment that characterized the post-COVID investment period.
The lender consortium taking control includes major financial institutions: Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital. According to recent quarterly filings, debt holders have already implemented substantial markdowns, with FS KKR Capital Corp valuing the loans at 79 cents on the dollar and Apollo Debt Solutions at 74 cents. These write-downs reflect the deterioration in Medallia's operational and financial performance over the past five years, during which the company failed to meet revenue and profitability expectations originally underpinning the acquisition thesis.
The Medallia restructuring exemplifies broader stress across the private credit and software sectors. Business development companies holding similar exposures are trading at significant discounts to net asset value—the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio stood at approximately 0.74 as of end-March 2026, representing a 26% discount and the widest spread since October 2020. This dislocation underscores investor concerns about the sustainability of valuations assigned to software assets acquired when leverage was abundant and cost of capital was minimal.
Blackstone's Brad Marshall attributed Medallia's challenges to execution deficiencies rather than technological obsolescence from artificial intelligence, though broader market anxiety about software sector fundamentals persists. The transaction demonstrates the cyclical nature of private equity returns and the risks inherent in leveraged acquisitions of high-valuation software businesses during periods of compressed interest rate expectations. The complete elimination of equity will reverberate across institutional investor portfolios holding stakes in Thoma Bravo funds from the 2021 vintage period.
The lender consortium taking control includes major financial institutions: Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital. According to recent quarterly filings, debt holders have already implemented substantial markdowns, with FS KKR Capital Corp valuing the loans at 79 cents on the dollar and Apollo Debt Solutions at 74 cents. These write-downs reflect the deterioration in Medallia's operational and financial performance over the past five years, during which the company failed to meet revenue and profitability expectations originally underpinning the acquisition thesis.
The Medallia restructuring exemplifies broader stress across the private credit and software sectors. Business development companies holding similar exposures are trading at significant discounts to net asset value—the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio stood at approximately 0.74 as of end-March 2026, representing a 26% discount and the widest spread since October 2020. This dislocation underscores investor concerns about the sustainability of valuations assigned to software assets acquired when leverage was abundant and cost of capital was minimal.
Blackstone's Brad Marshall attributed Medallia's challenges to execution deficiencies rather than technological obsolescence from artificial intelligence, though broader market anxiety about software sector fundamentals persists. The transaction demonstrates the cyclical nature of private equity returns and the risks inherent in leveraged acquisitions of high-valuation software businesses during periods of compressed interest rate expectations. The complete elimination of equity will reverberate across institutional investor portfolios holding stakes in Thoma Bravo funds from the 2021 vintage period.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.