Key Takeaways
- • Thoma Bravo is transferring ownership of customer experience software firm Medallia to its lenders, wiping out approximately $5.1 billion in equity after acquiring the company for $6.4 billion in October 2021.
- • Lenders including Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital—who collectively hold $3 billion in Medallia debt—are taking control through debt-for-equity conversion, with FS KKR Capital marking debt at 79 cents on the dollar and Apollo Debt Solutions at 74 cents.
- • The failure represents one of the most significant private equity collapses of the post-pandemic buyout cycle, reflecting widespread stress in software valuations during the era of near-zero interest rates and subsequent market deterioration.
- • Private credit sector faces acute systemic stress, with business development companies trading at a 26% discount to net asset values (0.74 price-to-forward NAV ratio) as of end-March 2026—the widest discount since October 2020.
- • Blackstone's private credit leadership attributed Medallia's underperformance to "execution-driven issues" rather than technology trends, highlighting operational risk management failures in the original acquisition thesis.
Summary
Thoma Bravo is finalizing an agreement to hand over Medallia, a customer experience software platform, to its lenders after the investment deteriorated sharply from its 2021 acquisition price. The private equity firm acquired Medallia for $6.4 billion in October 2021 at the peak of the low-interest-rate environment, betting aggressively on the software sector. The restructuring eliminates approximately $5.1 billion in equity value held by Thoma Bravo and co-investors, representing one of the most substantial write-offs among major private equity transactions since the pandemic-era buyout boom.
Control of Medallia will transfer to a consortium of sophisticated credit investors including Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital, who collectively hold $3 billion in company debt. The lenders have already absorbed significant losses through debt markdowns, with FS KKR Capital valuing the loans at 79 cents on the dollar in its latest quarterly disclosure and Apollo Debt Solutions marking the position at just 74 cents. The debt-for-equity conversion mechanism allows creditors to assume ownership rather than liquidate the company, preserving enterprise value while shifting equity risk entirely away from the sponsor.
The Medallia collapse reflects deeper stress within both the private equity and private credit markets. Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall indicated in February 2026 that Medallia's underperformance stemmed from "execution-driven issues" rather than sector headwinds or artificial intelligence disruption, suggesting operational management failures at the portfolio company level. The restructuring occurs as business development companies face their most severe valuation pressures in over five years, with the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio declining to approximately 0.74 by end-March 2026—implying a 26% discount that matches levels not seen since October 2020.
Software-heavy portfolios have become particularly vulnerable in the current environment, creating systemic concerns for private credit funds with concentrated sector exposure. The Medallia transaction underscores how the abundant capital and low cost of debt during 2020-2021 enabled aggressive acquisition multiples that are proving unsustainable as interest rates have normalized and market conditions have tightened. For institutional investors with exposure to private credit funds and software-focused private equity vehicles, the Medallia outcome signals elevated structural risk and the importance of deeper operational scrutiny during due diligence and portfolio monitoring processes.
Control of Medallia will transfer to a consortium of sophisticated credit investors including Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital, who collectively hold $3 billion in company debt. The lenders have already absorbed significant losses through debt markdowns, with FS KKR Capital valuing the loans at 79 cents on the dollar in its latest quarterly disclosure and Apollo Debt Solutions marking the position at just 74 cents. The debt-for-equity conversion mechanism allows creditors to assume ownership rather than liquidate the company, preserving enterprise value while shifting equity risk entirely away from the sponsor.
The Medallia collapse reflects deeper stress within both the private equity and private credit markets. Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall indicated in February 2026 that Medallia's underperformance stemmed from "execution-driven issues" rather than sector headwinds or artificial intelligence disruption, suggesting operational management failures at the portfolio company level. The restructuring occurs as business development companies face their most severe valuation pressures in over five years, with the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio declining to approximately 0.74 by end-March 2026—implying a 26% discount that matches levels not seen since October 2020.
Software-heavy portfolios have become particularly vulnerable in the current environment, creating systemic concerns for private credit funds with concentrated sector exposure. The Medallia transaction underscores how the abundant capital and low cost of debt during 2020-2021 enabled aggressive acquisition multiples that are proving unsustainable as interest rates have normalized and market conditions have tightened. For institutional investors with exposure to private credit funds and software-focused private equity vehicles, the Medallia outcome signals elevated structural risk and the importance of deeper operational scrutiny during due diligence and portfolio monitoring processes.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.