Key Takeaways
- • Thoma Bravo will lose the entire $5 billion it invested in Medallia, marking the second-largest private equity loss on record, after taking the customer experience software company private in a $6.4 billion deal in 2021.
- • A Blackstone-led consortium of private credit lenders—including Apollo and FS KKR Capital Corp—will assume control of Medallia, receiving $150 million in new capital while Medallia's debt outstanding stands at $2.8 billion.
- • The collapse stems from multiple compounding factors: rising debt costs over five years, the retreat of follow-on PE buyers, declining software industry growth, and Thoma Bravo founder Orlando Bravo's public acknowledgment that the firm overpaid for the asset.
- • The restructuring demonstrates the convergence of private equity and private credit strategies, with debt holders executing a de facto loan-to-own transition that transfers equity ownership from Thoma Bravo to the lender consortium.
- • The Medallia investment was made through Thoma Bravo Fund XIV, a $17.8 billion 2021 vintage vehicle with 98 institutional investors including major pension funds such as CalPERS and the Alaska Retirement Management Board, exposing significant institutional capital to the loss.
Summary
Thoma Bravo's acquisition of Medallia has resulted in a historic capital destruction event in the private equity industry. The software specialist took Medallia private on an all-cash basis for $6.4 billion in 2021, but will now surrender complete ownership to a lender consortium led by Blackstone, with Apollo and FS KKR Capital Corp as co-investors. The loss of Thoma Bravo's $5 billion equity investment represents the second-largest PE loss on record and signals a fundamental breakdown in the firm's value creation thesis for the customer experience software company.
The lender group—which provided debt financing for the original take-private—has taken control through a restructuring announced in mid-June 2026. Medallia's outstanding debt totals $2.8 billion, and the acquiring consortium will inject $150 million in fresh capital. This transaction exemplifies the growing convergence between private equity and private credit, where secured lenders effectively execute a loan-to-own strategy by converting their senior debt positions into equity ownership when sponsors cannot service or refinance obligations.
Multiple structural and market factors contributed to the deal's deterioration. Rising cost of debt over the five-year holding period significantly eroded returns, while the retreat of secondary PE buyers—who traditionally provide liquidity through follow-on acquisitions—removed a potential exit pathway. The software industry's deceleration in growth rates further pressured Medallia's financial performance and exit multiples. Orlando Bravo, Thoma Bravo's founder, has publicly conceded that the firm overpaid for the asset at acquisition. According to external analysis, the failure reflects a distinction between "software built to be flipped and software built to last," suggesting execution challenges in translating the acquisition into sustainable business improvement.
The impact extends across Thoma Bravo's institutional investor base. The Medallia investment was sourced from Fund XIV, the firm's 2021 vintage $17.8 billion buyout vehicle, which counts 98 institutional investors including major U.S. pension funds such as the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the Alaska Retirement Management Board, as well as the UK's Border to Coast Pensions Partnership. These public pension allocations to the fund will absorb their proportional share of the $5 billion loss, underscoring the ripple effects of large-scale private equity underperformance across institutional portfolios.
The lender group—which provided debt financing for the original take-private—has taken control through a restructuring announced in mid-June 2026. Medallia's outstanding debt totals $2.8 billion, and the acquiring consortium will inject $150 million in fresh capital. This transaction exemplifies the growing convergence between private equity and private credit, where secured lenders effectively execute a loan-to-own strategy by converting their senior debt positions into equity ownership when sponsors cannot service or refinance obligations.
Multiple structural and market factors contributed to the deal's deterioration. Rising cost of debt over the five-year holding period significantly eroded returns, while the retreat of secondary PE buyers—who traditionally provide liquidity through follow-on acquisitions—removed a potential exit pathway. The software industry's deceleration in growth rates further pressured Medallia's financial performance and exit multiples. Orlando Bravo, Thoma Bravo's founder, has publicly conceded that the firm overpaid for the asset at acquisition. According to external analysis, the failure reflects a distinction between "software built to be flipped and software built to last," suggesting execution challenges in translating the acquisition into sustainable business improvement.
The impact extends across Thoma Bravo's institutional investor base. The Medallia investment was sourced from Fund XIV, the firm's 2021 vintage $17.8 billion buyout vehicle, which counts 98 institutional investors including major U.S. pension funds such as the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the Alaska Retirement Management Board, as well as the UK's Border to Coast Pensions Partnership. These public pension allocations to the fund will absorb their proportional share of the $5 billion loss, underscoring the ripple effects of large-scale private equity underperformance across institutional portfolios.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.