Key Takeaways
- • Western & Southern Financial Group allocates 6% of its $65 billion portfolio to equities, triple the 2% industry average for life insurers, driven by exceptional capital surplus and a total return investment mandate.
- • The insurer's higher equity allocation has generated outperformance, with portfolio net income growing 12% over the past decade compared to the 3.44% average 10-year yield across the life and health insurance industry.
- • Co-CIOs Brendan White and Christopher Shipley manage both Western & Southern's core portfolio and Fort Washington Investment Advisors' $30 billion in third-party OCIO assets, enabling an integrated investment approach across $95 billion in total assets under management.
- • Western & Southern maintains 83% fixed income allocation to match insurance liabilities while deploying approximately $5 billion in public equities and $1.5 billion (2%) in private equity, reflecting a differentiated risk posture relative to peer insurers.
- • The strategy exemplifies how well-capitalized insurers can diverge from traditional liability-matching investment frameworks, positioning OCIOs as increasingly competitive alternatives for institutional capital management as the insurance industry explores higher-yielding private assets.
Summary
Western & Southern Financial Group is pursuing an atypical investment strategy within the life insurance sector, deploying materially higher equity allocations than industry peers while maintaining strong capital buffers. The insurer allocates approximately 6% of its $65 billion portfolio to equities—three times the 2% average among life insurers—supplemented by a 2% allocation to private equity totaling roughly $1.5 billion. This positioning reflects a deliberate departure from the risk-averse posture that typically defines insurance asset allocation, where companies historically match liabilities through bond-heavy portfolios.
The strategic differentiation stems from Western & Southern's substantial capital surplus, which permits management flexibility to pursue total return objectives rather than pure liability matching. According to Brendan White, co-chief investment officer of both Western & Southern and its investment management arm Fort Washington Investment Advisors, "Because of our surplus of capital, we have a higher allocation to equity than our peers, which has driven our growth." White and co-CIO Christopher Shipley oversee Western & Southern's $65 billion in assets while simultaneously managing approximately $30 billion through Fort Washington's OCIO business serving third-party institutional clients, concentrating approximately $95 billion in total assets under their joint mandate.
The equity-weighted approach has delivered measurable performance benefits. Western & Southern's portfolio net income has grown 12% over the past decade, substantially exceeding the 3.44% average 10-year yield reported by AM Best across the broader life and health insurance industry. The insurer maintains discipline through continued fixed income exposure of 83% to backstop policy liabilities, while the equity and private equity allocations—totaling roughly $6.5 billion—capture upside participation as equity markets have outperformed traditional bond allocations.
This strategy illustrates a broader sectoral shift as life insurers increasingly explore private asset allocations while OCIOs gain traction as alternative managers for institutional capital. Western & Southern's model demonstrates that capital-rich insurers can sustain higher-risk, higher-return mandates without compromising policyholder protections, while simultaneously enabling their investment arms to compete for external institutional assets under similar investment philosophies. The approach signals growing sophistication among insurance allocators in portfolio construction and highlights OCIOs' expanding role in managing diversified, return-oriented asset bases across the insurance ecosystem.
The strategic differentiation stems from Western & Southern's substantial capital surplus, which permits management flexibility to pursue total return objectives rather than pure liability matching. According to Brendan White, co-chief investment officer of both Western & Southern and its investment management arm Fort Washington Investment Advisors, "Because of our surplus of capital, we have a higher allocation to equity than our peers, which has driven our growth." White and co-CIO Christopher Shipley oversee Western & Southern's $65 billion in assets while simultaneously managing approximately $30 billion through Fort Washington's OCIO business serving third-party institutional clients, concentrating approximately $95 billion in total assets under their joint mandate.
The equity-weighted approach has delivered measurable performance benefits. Western & Southern's portfolio net income has grown 12% over the past decade, substantially exceeding the 3.44% average 10-year yield reported by AM Best across the broader life and health insurance industry. The insurer maintains discipline through continued fixed income exposure of 83% to backstop policy liabilities, while the equity and private equity allocations—totaling roughly $6.5 billion—capture upside participation as equity markets have outperformed traditional bond allocations.
This strategy illustrates a broader sectoral shift as life insurers increasingly explore private asset allocations while OCIOs gain traction as alternative managers for institutional capital. Western & Southern's model demonstrates that capital-rich insurers can sustain higher-risk, higher-return mandates without compromising policyholder protections, while simultaneously enabling their investment arms to compete for external institutional assets under similar investment philosophies. The approach signals growing sophistication among insurance allocators in portfolio construction and highlights OCIOs' expanding role in managing diversified, return-oriented asset bases across the insurance ecosystem.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.