Key Takeaways
- • Private equity's approach to fashion retail failed because PE firms applied grocery-sector logic and rapid scaling metrics to a relationship-driven, instinct-based industry that does not operate rationally like consumer staples—according to Lauren Santo Domingo, co-founder of Moda Operandi.
- • Major PE-backed fashion investments underperformed expectations, including Apax Digital Growth's $165 million funding round for Moda Operandi and its $1 billion acquisition of Matches Fashion, alongside L Catterton's majority stake purchase of Copenhagen's Ganni in 2017.
- • Founders and early-stage fashion entrepreneurs shifted strategy away from chasing large capital raises and headcount growth as primary success metrics, moving instead toward sustainable unit economics and founder-led decision-making.
- • The fashion investment boom (circa 2015–2018) saw venture and private-equity firms fund emerging brands like Anine Bing ($15 million Series A in 2018, followed by $13.5 million within months) and jewelry startup Mejuri, betting on rapid customer acquisition and scaling models that proved unsuitable for the sector.
- • Industry consensus emerged that PE's one-size-fits-all playbook—which succeeded in grocery and technology—cannot replicate results in fashion, where brand intuition, seasonal dynamics, and relationship capital drive value creation.
Summary
Private equity and venture capital's aggressive expansion into fashion retail has produced disappointing returns, exposing a fundamental mismatch between institutional investor playbooks and the operational realities of apparel and luxury goods markets. The fashion sector attracted significant institutional capital from 2015 onward, as investors sought to replicate the consolidation and scaling successes achieved in grocery retail and technology. However, the sector's dependency on creative instinct, brand relationships, and seasonal dynamics proved resistant to the standardized metrics and rapid growth mandates that define PE investment strategy.
Lauren Santo Domingo, co-founder of fashion e-commerce platform Moda Operandi, characterized the underlying misunderstanding bluntly: "Private-equity firms wanted to replicate the success that they had with the grocery sector, particularly in Canada. They thought that fashion is an equivalent industry because we have seasonal products. But you can't apply private-equity logic to a business that's so much about instinct and relationships." Moda Operandi itself raised $165 million in funding led by Apax Digital Growth, while the same fund simultaneously acquired London-based competitor Matches Fashion at a $1 billion valuation. These high-conviction bets underscored investor confidence in consolidation-driven returns.
Notable fashion brands that attracted substantial capital include Copenhagen-based apparel maker Ganni, which sold a majority stake to LVMH's investment vehicle L Catterton in 2017, and Los Angeles-based Anine Bing, which closed a $15 million Series A round in 2018 led by Felix Capital and Index Ventures, followed by a $13.5 million follow-on investment within months. Jewelry startup Mejuri, founded in 2015 during the PE boom, exemplified the era's capital abundance and growth-at-all-costs mentality. Industry participants noted that success became defined primarily by capital raised and employee headcount rather than sustainable unit economics or brand building—metrics ill-suited to fashion's margin structures and consumer preferences.
As capital discipline has returned to institutional investment, founders across fashion have recalibrated strategy, prioritizing founder control and operational sustainability over venture-scale growth trajectories. The sector's experience underscores a broader institutional investment lesson: standardized operational playbooks and financial engineering cannot overcome sector-specific dynamics rooted in taste, creativity, and relationship capital.
Lauren Santo Domingo, co-founder of fashion e-commerce platform Moda Operandi, characterized the underlying misunderstanding bluntly: "Private-equity firms wanted to replicate the success that they had with the grocery sector, particularly in Canada. They thought that fashion is an equivalent industry because we have seasonal products. But you can't apply private-equity logic to a business that's so much about instinct and relationships." Moda Operandi itself raised $165 million in funding led by Apax Digital Growth, while the same fund simultaneously acquired London-based competitor Matches Fashion at a $1 billion valuation. These high-conviction bets underscored investor confidence in consolidation-driven returns.
Notable fashion brands that attracted substantial capital include Copenhagen-based apparel maker Ganni, which sold a majority stake to LVMH's investment vehicle L Catterton in 2017, and Los Angeles-based Anine Bing, which closed a $15 million Series A round in 2018 led by Felix Capital and Index Ventures, followed by a $13.5 million follow-on investment within months. Jewelry startup Mejuri, founded in 2015 during the PE boom, exemplified the era's capital abundance and growth-at-all-costs mentality. Industry participants noted that success became defined primarily by capital raised and employee headcount rather than sustainable unit economics or brand building—metrics ill-suited to fashion's margin structures and consumer preferences.
As capital discipline has returned to institutional investment, founders across fashion have recalibrated strategy, prioritizing founder control and operational sustainability over venture-scale growth trajectories. The sector's experience underscores a broader institutional investment lesson: standardized operational playbooks and financial engineering cannot overcome sector-specific dynamics rooted in taste, creativity, and relationship capital.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.