Key Takeaways
- • The Bahamas Securities Commission is consulting on requiring contributory private pension plans to hire an investment manager licensed and registered by the regulator, a move that could raise fees and costs for plan participants.
- • Private pension plans in The Bahamas hold more than $1.5bn in retirement savings, according to the Securities Commission, yet employers offer them voluntarily and no legislation specifically governs their establishment or operation.
- • Former CG Atlantic Pensions chief operating officer Larry Gibson said higher fees "may be a small price to pay" for greater protection, citing conflicts of interest from employer-managed plans.
- • Industry voices, including RF Bank & Trust's David Slatter, called for comprehensive pension legislation, which has been debated for more than 30 years without enactment.
- • The City Markets supermarket collapse in 2012 left employees fighting in the Supreme Court for over a decade to access pension assets invested in the company's former head office.
Summary
The Securities Commission's discussion paper warned that employer-run plans can create conflicts of interest, including investing plan assets into the sponsoring company's own business or real estate, commingling pension and operating funds, and concentrating holdings in one or two assets. It also flagged custody concerns and limited reporting to members. These risks were highlighted by the 2012 collapse of City Markets supermarket chain, whose employer-sponsored pension plan was largely invested in the company's former head office on the East-West Highway. Employees have pursued access to their retirement income through the Supreme Court for more than a decade without success.
Gibson said most Bahamian private pension plans already use independent managers and administrators, and that problems tend to arise in a few legacy in-house plans that have failed to make timely payments or have made loans back to the sponsoring company. He argued that licensed, regulated entities could be held accountable under rules and regulations.
The consultation covers only whether licensed investment managers should oversee pension assets. It does not address whether private pensions should be mandatory or broadly regulated, which the regulator described as a matter of public policy for the Government and Parliament. The Employees' Pension Fund Protection Bill 2012 was debated at second reading but never advanced into law. Gibson questioned why pension legislation has not progressed in 12 to 14 years, while David Slatter, vice-president of investments at RF Bank & Trust (Bahamas), said advocates have pushed for pension legislation for more than 30 years. Slatter noted that the US, Canada and the Cayman Islands provide such legal protections.
According to the Securities Commission, the Central Bank's 2017 survey found private plans covered 52,363 persons, about 25.7 percent of the workforce, mostly in hotels and restaurants, with 44.7 percent of plan assets held in government securities. Private pension assets fell from just over $1.1bn in 2007 to about $675m in 2011 as workers who lost jobs withdrew savings, according to the regulator citing Government data.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.