Key Takeaways
- • Sequoia Capital partner Shaun Maguire faces backlash after calling New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani an "Islamist" who "comes from a culture that lies about everything," with the posts drawing 5.6 million views on X as of July 23, according to CNN.
- • An open letter with more than 1,100 signatures, sent to Sequoia on July 9, demands a public apology and disciplinary action against Maguire; the signatures could not be independently verified by CNN.
- • The signatories threaten to contact Sequoia's limited partners, including family offices and sovereign wealth funds, if the firm does not publicly condemn the remarks and launch an internal investigation.
- • Sequoia has not responded to CNN's requests for comment; Maguire defended himself in a 30-minute follow-up video, apologizing to Indians and Muslims who are not Islamists.
- • A counter-letter with more than 1,400 tech leaders defends Maguire, calling his words "not hate speech" and framing the backlash as "ideological bullying."
Summary
An open letter sent to Sequoia on July 9 and signed by more than 1,100 people, including startup founders and business figures globally, condemns the comments and demands that the firm apologize and take disciplinary action. Hosam Arab, co-founder and CEO of Gulf fintech Tabby, signed the letter. Tabby raised funding from Sequoia Capital's India business before Sequoia spun that arm off in 2024. Arab said Maguire's remarks resonated because "It was Sequoia," a firm managing around $56 billion as of January. The letter's update warns that, absent a public condemnation and internal investigation covering Maguire's conduct over the past two years, signatories will contact Sequoia's limited partners. One Middle Eastern founder said they are reaching out to family offices and sovereign wealth funds, though Sequoia has not disclosed what share of its capital comes from such investors. Many regional companies have received Sequoia India funding, including a $33 million investment in Saudi fintech Lean Technologies in 2022.
Maguire, responding through a 30-minute follow-up video, said Islamists make up only a small fraction of Muslims and said he was "very, very sorry" to any Indians or Muslims who are not Islamists. He said, "This tweet did not land the way I thought it would." Sequoia has not responded to CNN's requests for comment, and Mamdani did not respond either. The Council on American-Islamic Relations said in a letter that Maguire's posting history reflects "a dangerous pattern of anti-Muslim hate speech." Abed Ayoub, national executive director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, said such rhetoric should not be accepted as part of political discourse.
Maguire has received support inside Sequoia and across the industry. On July 10, fellow partner Pat Grady issued a statement praising Maguire's courage while saying he does not agree with everything his partners say. A separate letter with more than 1,400 signatures defended Maguire, stating his words "were not hate speech" and opposing "ideological bullying." CNN reported that no public action has yet been taken by any Sequoia partner, and that the founders' letter is unlikely to materially affect the firm's finances.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.