Key Takeaways
- • Marc Andreessen directly disputed Carl Icahn's conflict-of-interest accusations on March 3, 2014, calling claims "false and misleading" and stating he fully disclosed his interests and recused himself from relevant board deliberations.
- • Icahn's primary criticism centers on Andreessen's involvement in the 2009 Skype acquisition from eBay and its subsequent 2011 sale to Microsoft at a significantly higher price, which generated substantial returns for Andreessen Horowitz and Silver Lake Partners.
- • Andreessen notes eBay's post-spin-off ownership stake in Skype was substantially larger than Andreessen Horowitz's stake, and emphasizes his 2012 board re-election with 99.7% shareholder support despite the prior transaction.
- • Icahn also alleged Andreessen holds conflicting investments in companies competing with eBay's PayPal division, questioning his objectivity in advising on PayPal's strategic direction.
- • Icahn, pursuing his fifth shareholder letter in one week, has nominated two replacement board directors and is actively campaigning for eBay to spin off PayPal as a separate entity.
Summary
Marc Andreessen, venture capitalist and eBay board director, issued a formal statement on Monday, March 3, 2014, rejecting activist investor Carl Icahn's allegations of board conflicts of interest. Andreessen stated he "disputes all accusations that I have violated any of my duties to eBay shareholders," emphasizing that he "fully disclosed my potential interest and recused myself from all deliberations on the transaction" related to Skype.
Icahn's conflict-of-interest argument rests on two primary grounds. First, Andreessen's venture capital firm, Andreessen Horowitz, participated in an investor group that acquired Skype from eBay in 2009 and subsequently sold it to Microsoft in 2011 at a substantially higher valuation, generating significant returns. Second, Icahn contended that Andreessen's investments in companies competing with eBay's PayPal division create an inherent bias against PayPal's strategic interests. In his correspondence, Icahn questioned how Andreessen could "objectively advise" eBay management on PayPal's direction given these competitive investments.
In his defense, Andreessen countered that eBay's ownership stake in Skype following the transaction's completion was substantially larger than Andreessen Horowitz's position, limiting the economic incentive argument. More significantly, he highlighted his re-election to the eBay board in 2012 with 99.7% shareholder approval, suggesting broad institutional confidence in his continued service despite knowledge of the Skype transaction.
Icahn escalated his campaign on the same day, issuing his fifth shareholder letter within a week. He declared that "Mr. Andreessen's conflicts are clear and insurmountable," and noted that eBay declined CNBC's offer for a televised debate between himself and company leadership. Icahn has nominated two replacement directors—to replace Andreessen and former Intuit CEO Scott Cook—and continues advocating for PayPal's separation from eBay as a standalone public company.
Icahn's conflict-of-interest argument rests on two primary grounds. First, Andreessen's venture capital firm, Andreessen Horowitz, participated in an investor group that acquired Skype from eBay in 2009 and subsequently sold it to Microsoft in 2011 at a substantially higher valuation, generating significant returns. Second, Icahn contended that Andreessen's investments in companies competing with eBay's PayPal division create an inherent bias against PayPal's strategic interests. In his correspondence, Icahn questioned how Andreessen could "objectively advise" eBay management on PayPal's direction given these competitive investments.
In his defense, Andreessen countered that eBay's ownership stake in Skype following the transaction's completion was substantially larger than Andreessen Horowitz's position, limiting the economic incentive argument. More significantly, he highlighted his re-election to the eBay board in 2012 with 99.7% shareholder approval, suggesting broad institutional confidence in his continued service despite knowledge of the Skype transaction.
Icahn escalated his campaign on the same day, issuing his fifth shareholder letter within a week. He declared that "Mr. Andreessen's conflicts are clear and insurmountable," and noted that eBay declined CNBC's offer for a televised debate between himself and company leadership. Icahn has nominated two replacement directors—to replace Andreessen and former Intuit CEO Scott Cook—and continues advocating for PayPal's separation from eBay as a standalone public company.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.