Key Takeaways
- • Martin Spiller, Associate Professor in Entrepreneurial Practice at Oxford Brookes Business School, argues that raising external equity should not be mistaken for business achievement, since funding simply means an investor now expects a return.
- • Spiller contends founders should define personal success and founder-business fit before deciding how to fund, rather than letting investor expectations set the strategy.
- • Spiller cites Wharton and University of Zurich research estimating that 88% of US venture-backed founders receive no value at exit, while the top 1% of founders captured 79% of the value.
- • Spiller recommends alternatives to equity such as customer deposits, staged payments, paid pilots, asset finance, invoice finance, grants and Start Up Loans, while noting each carries its own drawbacks.
- • Spiller frames a profitable, founder-controlled business as a legitimate outcome that needs no apology, not a failure to pursue growth.
Summary
Spiller acknowledges that equity can be valuable for capital-intensive businesses, citing Levi Roots' Reggae Reggae Sauce, which he says moved from Dragons' Den to supermarket shelves with the backing of two Dragons, and WhatsApp, which he notes received Sequoia's backing for less than three years before Facebook agreed to buy it for $19bn. He cautions, however, that equity brings a investor-driven return expectation. Angels invest their own money, while VC funds draw on pension funds, insurers and other institutions and need a handful of winners to return the entire fund. In his view, a founder-run business that is enjoyable and leaves room for a personal life may be incompatible with that model, making it an inappropriate investment rather than a bad business.
Spiller urges founders to examine founder-business fit alongside product-market fit, asking whether a business suits their ambitions, values and risk appetite, and whether they would still want the resulting lifestyle if it succeeded as planned. He recommends first establishing how much cash is needed, when, and for what purpose, through a cash-flow forecast that distinguishes between equipment purchases, customer payment delays and losses during market-share building. Non-equity options he lists include customer deposits, staged payments and paid pilots, prompt invoicing, asset finance, invoice finance, grants and Start Up Loans. He notes drawbacks, including the time required to secure and report on grants and the fact that many early-stage loans function as personal loans where business failure does not remove repayment obligations.
Spiller concludes that funding should serve the strategy rather than define it, and that a profitable business supporting a family, creating decent jobs and offering control over working life needs no justification. He notes that the article is contributed by a guest author and that Startups.co.uk and MVF do not endorse its views. Spiller is a Partner at Oakmere Partners, a UK SME acquisition firm, and a Fellow of the ICAEW and qualified barrister with more than thirty years of experience as a corporate financier, CFO, academic, adviser and investor.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.